DD 13, is not shy was excited about going to the Stack on our last cruise . She & a 16 yr. old table mate went up the first night for the 411. They felt most of the kids acted like jerks & the activities were a bid childish, but they are a little bit more mature for their age than some. They hung out the entire cruise together & had a blast, so it was fine in the end. She just wasn't pleased with the types of kids in there. Everyone was try to impress everyone else- very phony... that got old real quick with her.
We were in Mickey Mates one day & this 15 or 16 yr. old kid was having a snitty fit like a toddler over something his parents refused to buy. My DD turned to me & said. Oh, that's "Mr. Big Shot" from the Stack. Isn't he impressive Mom? LOL!! I can see why she didn't stay if they were like him... If there is a good group of kids onboard I would think it would be fun.