Survivor All Star OFFICIAL THREAD!

[Beanie]

Originally posted by cheyita
Okay - I thought Alicia was the best to go once Shii-Ann won immunity. But I didn't hear -- what did Alicia say to Shii-Ann after the results were announced? Thanks!

I would also like to know what Alicia said...I couldn't make it out!

 

[pirateofthecarolinas]

Me too!

Anyone have TIVO? My children were talking and I couldn't hear it.

Lori

 

[DemonLlama]

No, we are seeing one hour of the most heavily edited program on television! They are living with one another 24/7 and the producers are manipulating us, not them, into casting their respective personas.

 

[Grog]

we only see 1 hour a week, and WE can see what Rob's up to; don't they have any idea???????? Stupid, stupid people!

The problem is that all these people have alliances of one form or another with Rob, and they are naive enough to believe that he will honor it. What I would like to see is one person from one alliance talking to another... "What do you mean you have an alliance with Rob...I have an alliance with Rob! Oh, Rob...can we have a word with you please". I just find it so hard to believe that these people don't compare notes with each other.

 

[NHAnn]

We played back what Alicia said a few times and couldn't make it out...I thought it was "well someone turned on me...and I better not find out who........" or something to that effect.......

 

[faithinkarma]

I have to admit I almost felt sorry for Alicia when she said she had shaken hands with Rob......not the first person Rob has shaken with and betrayed.

But I have to wonder if Alicia would have been so readily boooted if she had not gotten on everyone's nerves so much after the reward challenge.

 

[palmtreegirl]

What a bunch of ding-dongs they had their chance to vote of Rob and didn't take it- silly people.

I love Boston Rob, he is way too funny and playing the game brilliantly(so far) after this week he deserves to take it all.

 

[faithinkarma]

What a bunch of ding-dongs they had their chance to vote of Rob and didn't take it- silly people.

You know, I have hated him all along. But after this week I am softening. He is playing a great game.

 

[newholiday]

OMG! What we do for friends!
Just realized as I was logging onto the computer that I missed Survivor! Spent the past 3hrs in the emergency room

So what was the challenge?

 

[faithinkarma]

for the immunity challenge each contestant had to stand on what looked like a tree stump. Suspended over each of their heads was a bucket of water. Attached to the bucket was a chain that ended in a handcuff. The handcuff was put around one wrist. They had to keep their arm extended up over their head or the bucket would tip and douse them thus eliminating them. There was no more than 2 inches of slack in the chain. A very difficult challeenge.

It lasted over 2 hours. Rupert was the second last to douse himself. Rob was just vefore him I believe.

Amber was the first.

 

[sydally9367]

Just when I thought this episode would be a snooooooozer...Shi-Ann pulls one out
The predictability of this show re: Ambuh and Boston Rob is just so boring, I really hope someone pulls their head of their hiney and realizes what's going on or why even bother watching?
I don't like or have EVER liked Shi-Ann, but I was happy to see her win immunity. It was sickening watch them not support her or root her on...not even congratulate her on holding on for so long!!! I know she was cocky at the end of the challenge, but heck, I would've been too after all that!
I'd like to see someone shake it up next week ...maybe get rid of Jenna or for a long shot......Rob

 

[izzy]

What did y'all think of Lex's mohawk (or whatever that was!)?

It certainly was, shall I say, "different!"

 

[faithinkarma]

It certainly was, shall I say, "different!"

So is Lex LOL

 

[Samandmom]

Originally posted by sydally9367
I don't like or have EVER liked Shi-Ann, but I was happy to see her win immunity. It was sickening watch them not support her or root her on...not even congratulate her on holding on for so long!!! I know she was cocky at the end of the challenge, but heck, I would've been too after all that!

I also was happy to see her win. (I don't like her either) But it really shook up the game.

 

[Yzma and Kronk]

I almost felt bad for ShiiAnn. Even though it was heavily edited, I didn't think there was any call for the way the others treated her. I'm so glad she won and I don't blame her for gloating.

She certainly was the odd man out - but to blame her for making fun of the fact she got the rice.......all I can say is Jenna is such a dolt! And Rob making the comment about the hamburger. He was second pick - he could have had what he wanted - jerk!

What was with Tom and Rupert. I thought they were buds and would stick together??? I thought it was a ploy to throw us off that they may have voted Rob out.

Finally, I agree........stupid, stupid, stupid people!

But I loved the rolling eyes and snickers when Kathy and Lex came in. Plus Alicia isn't going to give the $$ to Rob - so it's 3 to 0 for the other person if Rob makes it to the final two!

 

[Grog]

I don't blame her for gloating.

Same here. I think she was actually kind of restrained. I would have been a lot more "in your face" to the others than she was, even though I knew I would be out at the next possible opportunity. They made absoultely no secret they were getting rid of her, then they get upset when she shows emotion at winning the most important challenge (to her) so far.

 

[deadheadbelle]

I thought it was great that they didn't really go to her (Shiiann) with their plans. Like Jenna said, why would they? Everyone thinks they have the numbers, so why would they bother letting her in on it? Why give her ammunition to try & sway the other tribemates?

I think the final four will be Rob, Amber, Jenna & Tom.

What do you guys think?

 

[Grog]

Rob, Amber, Jenna & Tom.

I think substitute Rupert for Tom. I think when it gets to five, Rupert wins immunity and Tom is gone.

 

[Chess]

I was glad to see Shi-Ann win immunity and I wish they would have gotten rid of Rob. The only reason that I can think of that they are not getting rid of him at this point and probably won't is you now have 3 people on the jury who will most likely not vote for him to win the $$$ unless their anger has cooled by the time the voting happens. If I had to go up against someone at this point I would probably pick Rob because he is beeing seen as the string puller. I would love the final 2 to be Tom and Rupert.

 

[AZKathy]

I was so happy to see ShiAnn win the immunity. I have not cared much for her in the show, but I was so sick of the other people trying to vote her off and then rooting for Rupert during the last two up for immunity. I don't blame her for gloating and the other people were terrible for their actions afterwards.

DUMB DUMB DUMB people for not voting off Rob! They had the chance and they blew it! DUMB!!!!!