Survivor All Star OFFICIAL THREAD!

[faithinkarma]

So, what you're saying is that it's ok to stab a friend in the chest, just not in the back, right ?

I don't believe that is what I said at all.

Lex did not promise Ethan anything. Rob promised Lex something. I see a difference in the situations.

I do not see evicting someone who is your friend outside the game as a betrayal. What Rob did was evict someone he had promised to protect.

However, I do agree with you that Rob showed some class when he told Lex his plans.

And I also agree that Rob seems to be playing a brilliant game. What I was commenting on was Rob's loyalty or lack thereof.

And wvrevy, I really hate disagreeing with you beause I have read so many of your posts elsewhere and always agree with you.

 

[wvrevy]

Originally posted by faithinkarma
And wvrevy, I really hate disagreeing with you beause I have read so many of your posts elsewhere and always agree with you.

Hey, my best friend in the world is a staunch Republican and Bush supporter, so if I can get along with him, I can get along with anybody

I guess I just don't see it that way...I really think that, if you're friends with someone outside the game, you can't exactly join up with relative strangers against them inside of it and then say that it shouldn't have anything to do with the friendship. At least, you can't do that then whine when someone does the same to you later

Technically, Rob "promised" Lex to "take care of" him...and I'd say he took care of him pretty well last night

 

[gometros]

Originally posted by DISshopkeeper
Man, I can't believe that it's more than an hour after the show and not one comment?? I see the OTHER thread, but geez....

What other thread?

 

[DISshopkeeper]

This one:

http://www.disboards.com/showthread.php?s=&threadid=544915&highlight=+i++hate++rob

It's just WONDERFUL to have search back!!!

Edited to add: WARNING!!!! If you are avoiding RUMORS I think there are some in that other thread. I averted my eyes in time, but I think they are there.

 

[faithinkarma]

Technically, Rob "promised" Lex to "take care of" him...and I'd say he took care of him pretty well last night

yep, on this one we are in complete agreement

 

[StaceyA]

Originally posted by Grog
I got tied up answering a couple of long e-mails right after the show.

Rob is a worm. yes, he's playing the game, but Lex did him a MAJOR favor. He should have helped Lex this one time, then let him know they were even. It didn't seem to sit well with Ambah, that Rob was going to stab Lex in the back. Rob seems to really care about her. I hope she dumps him.

I just read in the new Peoples mag that they are still together and talking marriage.....

 

[BCVOwner2002]

I like Rob too and I'm glad he got rid of Lex. I don't like what he did to his team over the past few weeks. Who is he to talk about friendship? It's a game! Get over it!!!

This is by far the best survivor I've watched! It's amazing to watch how each of them are playing the game compared to the first time they were on. The old saying if I could do it over again . . . well here is their chance. Some are definitely playing better than others.

I think Kathy already planned a small alliance with the other tribe. I'm glad she didn't give up her immunity to Lex. She deserves to stay in the game. Shi-Ann is way under the radar for the moment and since she isn't a threat to anyone she could last longer than Kathy. Rob's tribe appears to be sticking together. I am really curious as to who will be in the final four. Can't wait for next week.

My son will graduate this year from the same private high school that Rob graduated from.

 

[Tulirose]

Two weeks without Survivor -- So glad the VCR worked and also adjusted to the change in time!

Loved reading all your thoughts and comments.

My choice for Final Four:

Rob
Amber
Kathy

... well, let's just make that my choice for the final three because I can't decide on either Rupert, Alicia or Big Tom for the fourth one.

I would really like to see Rob win. If not him, then Kathy.

 

[phamton]

This is exactly what Rob said to Lex : "If you take care of her, I'll take care of you....If you can, if you can"

 

[WilliamsMom]

I can't imagine why Lex trusted Rob especially since this is ALLSTARS. Everyone saw how Rob acted in his previous Survivor show. It doesn't take a brain surgeon to realize you can't trust him. I didn't like Geri either so it was a tough call.

I don't think this is the best Survivor at all. Half the fun of Survivor is figuring out people's personalities and their strategies.

 

[Alice28]

All right, who is going home tonight? Any thoughts?

The previews point the finger to Jenna...my thoughts are on either ShiiAnn, or for some reason, Alicia. Of course, I would like the Rob/Amber alliance broken up, or at least questioned, but I don't think that's gonna happen this week.

We're supposed to go out to dinner tonight, but hopefully I won't miss any Survivor!

 

[cheyita]

I'm leaning toward Shii-Ann. I think Alicia has a chance of being isolated, but I don't think she deserves it. And I think she has a better chance at getting immunity than Shii-Ann does.

 

[faithinkarma]

Darn, I have not seen any previews. But I guess if they point to Jenna we can be pretty certain it is not her.

I know who I would like to see get the boot, but I have no predictions.

I am still wondering what went on that we have not seen. There has to be some reason Rob did not boot one of the weaker women and fulfill his obligation to Lex last week. Besides the obvious one that he can knock off the women whenever he wants to.

 

[Alice28]

My thoughts on Alicia are based on nothing; I like her. But I just get the feeling that if someone else has the finger pointed at them, they won't hesitate to clamor to get Alicia out, as she is the strongest woman (physically) and at times has clashed with others. I hope for the final 4 that it is Rupert, Big Tom, Kathy & Alicia.

 

[Tulirose]

Feeling isolated, Kathy works to reconcile with a tribemate.

After several castaways are brought to tears, one Survivor surprises all.

The stakes are raised when the All-Stars are hit with a new twist at the Immunity Challenge.

Scrambling, panic and pleading intensify as Tribal Council approaches.


Don't miss all the action
Thursday, April 15 at 8pm ET/PT.



Personally, I would like to see Shii-Ann go next but I fear she won't be the next one on the hit parade. What will happen tonight, I haven't a clue. Wonder what new twist happens at this immunity challenge? Scrambling, panic and pleading! Hmmm.... Should be an interesting evening.

 

[newholiday]

OMG! this is a tear jerker
now what do we think of Rob?

 

[izzy]

"Wow, what a shock," she said sarcastically.

Honestly, this All-Stars is SO predictable, it's not even that much fun to watch anymore.

 

[tiggersmom2]

I just can't believe they didn't break Ambuh and Rob up! I'm really disappointed in Rupert and Jenna

 

[Tulirose]

When Kathy said she was voting for the person who lied to her, I thought OMG Amber is going to go. I thought Kathy worked some magic and convinced the others to break up the romantic duo but she failed.

I liked Kathy. I really wanted her to win in Marqueses and I would have liked to have seen her go much much further on this one but it was not to be.

If Rob ever loses immunity, you would think he would be history but I'm not sure about that now. I think they are really afraid to go against him.

 

[faithinkarma]

I'm really sorry to see Kathy go.

Question? How did Lex grow hair that long in a couple of days? I may be not remembering correctly, but it seems to me it was pretty short when he left. Now all of a sudden it is standing up several inches? Actually he kinda looked like my son the year I dressed him as Mr T