I love a pouch (most of the controversy was over deep pouches, IIRC, the ones that are like duffle bags and allow baby to get all smoothed up in the bottom) but I don't think it's the best choice for long days at the parks. I would definitely got for something two-shouldered to help distribute the weight. Have you looked at a Baby K'Tan, or an Asian-style carrier such as a mei-tai like they sell at Babyhawk or Kozy Karrier? I assume you don't want the excess fabric and learning curve of a Moby-style wrap? They are the most hands-free to me, but also the most difficult to put on quickly. A Baby K'Tan is kind of like a wrap that's been sewn IN the wrap mode, if you get what I mean. Lots of moms I know love it. Good luck in your search, and congratulations on a positive nursing relationship!