Honestly, stick with the Yacht Club Galley. I just posted a favorite review on another post but that's not why I'm suggesting you keep your original plans. Everyone's opinion on a restaurant is going to be different. If you haven't tried it yourself, then you'll never know. I shied away from Teppanyaki for years because "It's just another Beni-hana". We had one of the best lunches there on Thanksgiving day.
Another time, I made reservations for a special meal at the California Grill based on reviews. I knew it was a tad too expensive for my husband's taste but figured the great food and atmosphere would make up for the price. We had what I would call an "OK" meal. Husband doesn't ever want to go back and not just because of the price tag. He just didn't like anything about it and I should have just listened to instinct and not done it at all.
So, chuck the reviews, check the menus, and go with what YOU want.