I have a DD9. We usually put some lip glosses and small bottles of nail polish. She still likes to collect Littlest Pet Shop animals, so I usually throw one or two in there. Sometimes she gets a small Build A Bear gift card, along with one from her favorite pizza place. And much to my surprise, she still expects Silly Putty and a small Slinky every year.

I figured she wouldn't care about those anymore, but I guess it became a tradition for her. So I usually grab those from the bargain bins at Target.