Staying at Beach club... Captains Grille Dinner or Trattoria?

momtwoboys

DIS Veteran
Joined
Dec 9, 2007
Messages
4,474
looking for something that is not signature for a dinner. Already have Cape May for dinner another night and Beaches and cream for another. Trying to minimize busing all over for dinner. thanks!
 
I can't speak to Captain's Grille because I've never eaten there but we ate at Trattoria last summer. It was excellent! I'd definitely recommend it and I am hoping to eat there again this summer.
 
I can't speak to Captain's Grille because I've never eaten there but we ate at Trattoria last summer. It was excellent! I'd definitely recommend it and I am hoping to eat there again this summer.

Same here. We had a wonderful meal there in June. I would not hesitate to go there again.
 
We've enjoyed our meals at Captain's Grille along with a casual dinner at Crew's Cup lounge in YC. The YC Concierge recommended Crew's Cup and he prefers it over Beaches and Cream.
 
Been to both once, Trattoria would be my choice. Capts Grille for me, only memorable thing was seeing Penny Marshall(Laverne). Food was not that good and we were really excited to try something new. Trattoria food was really good. I cant say it became a must do every trip but will be on our radar for the future for a every once in a while
 
I highly recommend Trattoria! It was so good we went twice during our Sept trip. We also ate at Captains Grille (we were staying at Yacht Club). Food was good, service was lousy. I'd pick Trattoria hands down. Ask for Dale as your server.
 
We have had dinner at Captain's Grill several times and had good meals each time. We tried Trattoria in December. Excellent experience! Our waitress was fantastic, the service and food were great!
 
We had one of our all time best meals at Disney at Captain's Grille. We ended up dining there because of a last minute change of plans due to the weather and we were all very pleasantly surprised. The food was very good.
 
looking for something that is not signature for a dinner. Already have Cape May for dinner another night and Beaches and cream for another. Trying to minimize busing all over for dinner. thanks!
We LOVE Captains Grill!!! No doubt that would be our choice. We are actually going out of our way for it along with Cape May Cafe also a great choice!!!!!
 
DH and I ate at Captain's a year ago. I thought it was good, but felt it was kind of pricey for what I got (even compared to other Disney meals). I met a friend at Trattoria during my solo Sept. trip. The service was the friendliest and most attentive I've had. Food was good. My friend said his meal was delicious.
 
Glad to hear the good reviews or Trattoria. DH and I have an ADR here Star Wars half marathon weekend. My carbo load meal. :)
 
thanks everyone we have a dinner planned for Trattoria april 19th! wonder if I should keep beaches n cream or try capt grille. What exactly is the crews cup anyway? have eaten many times at Cape may and never recall seeing it?
 
thanks everyone we have a dinner planned for Trattoria april 19th! wonder if I should keep beaches n cream or try capt grille. What exactly is the crews cup anyway? have eaten many times at Cape may and never recall seeing it?

Glad you picked Trattoria! We've eaten there a few times and have always enjoyed it.

Yes, I would switch B&C to Capt. Grille. The food at Capt. Grille is much, much better. I find the food at B&C to be quite greasy. Great sundaes though!

Crews Cup is a lounge. I would stick with Trattoria and Capt. Grille. Maybe make a reservation after Capt. Grille for sundaes at B&C?
 
we can get ice cream to go anytime then! I will switch Beaches and cream for capt grill thanks!!!
 
We ate at Trattoria in November and is was great! Loved the Caprese Salad and the chicken parm was very good. We had great service and will be back next trip.
 
Can you just go in and order a Sunday to go at B&C without a ressie? If yes, do you order outside or go in?
 
last April we went into the little take out side, ordered a mini no way jose and took it outside and ate it all! they have simple ice cream cones and basic things, but told me if they arent too busy they can make other sundaes, just not the kitchen sink but we dont want that! I had a mini no way jose which still was huge to split 3 ways
 

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom