We just got back (and are just itching to return already). We requested either the Paddock section, near the pool or the Springs section, near the pool. On arrival, we were given a choice between the closest building too the main pool or one of the two closest buildings to the Paddock pool. We picked the Paddock to try the new pool, and it was a very quickto get to the main pool-- walk across the bridge and past the Springs Buiding that we could have chose to stay in.
We spent equal time at both pools. Both have crafts (although the Main pool has them inside at the Community Hall all day long), both have great slides, both have hot tubs (Main one has two), both have pool side bars, both have food options (Artist Pallete is more extensive, but no burgers), both have DJs who come and do afternnoon party fun and games. Our kids (11, 9, and 7) liked the Paddock slide the best.
If you have any young kids (8 and under), try and stay in the Paddock Area near the pool. It also has a great small slide/water play area. Think playground with water. If you have no kids or older kids-- either one is great.
Really, the only are I would not want to stay in is the Carousel-- too far and no pool. All others have their own good things (Grandstand: pool, water gun/ splash area, food, hot tub, first stop for buses in and out of SSR, quick walk to Main Pool), Congress (pool, views and DDT). Yes, SSR is big, but to us it is like getting to try a new resort each time with the same easy access to all the things we love.