Whether it's due to the dining plan or just pure economics of money and time, many restaurants at WDW seem to have become more formulaic and I'm afraid not the best representations of the individual chefs' capabilities. It's one of the reasons I enjoy the Food & Wine festival so much! It's not just about the visiting celebrity chefs; there are a number of events that allow the WDW chefs to shine, too, including the Food & Wine pairings at the Epcot restaurants and the Signature Dinners at the resort restaurants!
Since this thread is about Spoodles, here's my story of Spoodles' Chef Tony. Granted, I still haven't yet made it over to Spoodles recently enough to try the new menu so I don't have a comparison to the restaurant's current bill of fare. However, I attended two festival events that he participated in -- a Party For the Senses and an Exquisite Evening -- two separate events with quite different price points and presentations.
For the PFTS (9/29), he prepared a cheese ravioli with eggplant and sundried tomato. It was quite tasty, although perhaps too familiar in ingredients to stand out like Chef TJ's (Boma) ostrach bobotie did for many at my table.
As tasty as that ravioli was, it was the Exquisite Evening that wowed me. He took responsibility for the cheese course. Now I've had many a cheese course and yes, I think Cali Grill, Jiko, and Flying Fish have offered amazing cheese courses. This cheese course, however, blew them all out of the water. Some accompaniments were more traditional to me than others. However, all perfectly complemented their cheese matches.
Murcia al Vino with Spice-candied Pecan Brittle
Pecorino Toscano with Fig Jam
Ubriaco al Borolo with Prosecco Grapes
Blue del Moncenisio with Sardinian Bitter Honey
Brunet with Amaretto-braised Cherries
It's such a shame that a cheese course like that doesn't fit into the Spoodles budget. Sigh.