My family did both, two nights apart. We liked Hoop Dee Doo better for both entertainment and food. The food at the Luau was mediocre at best, and the part we found most entertaining was the fire dancer. Hoop Dee Doo is corny, but our server was hilarious and dead-pan which works well with my family. The food was delicious (provided you like ribs and chicken) and I liked the show -- I do theater and it was cute.