I didn't use bluenile.com, but I got my wedding ring on Overstock.com. I didn't want a traditional band; I bought a silver filigree Victorian-style ring with black and white diamonds. For only $39. I get lots of compliments on it - even from complete strangers - and they almost always ask if it's an antique. Of course it doesn't match DH's ring, which is silver with a black Celtic knot running through it, but they complement each other. They're "different" and we like it that way.