Speaking of college majors: Don't work with children.

eliza61

DIS Legend
Joined
Jun 2, 2003
Messages
21,013
I found this immensely sad. The 10 worst paying college degrees are all the ones where we are working with our youth. :sad2:


If you want to avoid the worst-paying college degrees, think twice before choosing a college major that involves children.
Included among the 20 worst-paying college degrees are elementary education, special education, social work and child and family studies. That's the conclusion of the latest annual study of college degrees by Payscale, Inc. that compiled starting and mid-career pay for dozens of college majors.



Child and family studies earned the honors as the worst-paying college major. The average graduate earns a beginning salary of $29,500. What's equally discouraging is that the salary of someone in this field will barely budge after 15 years in the profession.


http://finance.yahoo.com/college-ed...-degrees-in-2010?mod=edu-continuing_education

Can we really be surprised when we can't get good people to teach our kids, I wish we valued teachers more.
 
Do you think it's because working with children has either been a state funded program or charity funded (almost like a non-profit situation). Not many people who work at the local government level, for for charity and non-profit groups ever make the money they deserve.

Now, if we could get these positions to be funded by some slick, for profit company these professions could get a bump up, but it's never gonna happen.
 
I'm a 3rd grade teacher and certainly don't get paid "well". But, I have the joy of working with children and seeing them grow, learn, and become people.

It's worth it, to me. :)
 
I'm a 3rd grade teacher and certainly don't get paid "well". But, I have the joy of working with children and seeing them grow, learn, and become people.

It's worth it, to me. :)

And pretty much, what could be more important? ;)
 
i have to wonder how accurate the data is for this study.

the one for a social work degree seems WAY off. i have'nt worked in the field for almost 7 years, but starting salaries for a degreed social worker were HUGELY higher than what they are reporting for mid career range.

just for the heck of it-i checked my former gov. employer's website to see what they were paying for newbie social workers (fresh out of college with a bachelor's degree)-their STARTING salary is over $53,000 a year, which gets bumped up 5% after 6 months, then has 3 more steps of 5% pay increases before it tops out. and that's just the entry level job-with a year of experience they can promote up to an sw2 at a much higher rate.

now, if they have an actual msw they are looking at MUCH more (it was the norm when i worked there that a new msw grad who financed their entire pre and post grad work would only end up working in children's services for 3 years b/c the salary they earned would be sufficient to pay off their student loans in their entirety so they would do so, quit and set up their own private practices).
 
i have to wonder how accurate the data is for this study.

the one for a social work degree seems WAY off. i have'nt worked in the field for almost 7 years, but starting salaries for a degreed social worker were HUGELY higher than what they are reporting for mid career range.

just for the heck of it-i checked my former gov. employer's website to see what they were paying for newbie social workers (fresh out of college with a bachelor's degree)-their STARTING salary is over $53,000 a year, which gets bumped up 5% after 6 months, then has 3 more steps of 5% pay increases before it tops out. and that's just the entry level job-with a year of experience they can promote up to an sw2 at a much higher rate.

now, if they have an actual msw they are looking at MUCH more (it was the norm when i worked there that a new msw grad who financed their entire pre and post grad work would only end up working in children's services for 3 years b/c the salary they earned would be sufficient to pay off their student loans in their entirety so they would do so, quit and set up their own private practices).

You have to look at national averages-social workers in our old town start at $20K, but it was a smaller town and a single person could live off of that there. Someone that has been working there a while and has a masters makes about 40K.
 
It is probably based on a BS, rather than a MSW. But then you are looking at 2 years work post degree.

Made a call. BSW will pay $29,000. MSW no license, $35,000. Licensed MSW, $53,000.
 
The average teacher salary in my school district is close to $80,000, plus great benefits. The lowest HS salary in our district is $45,000, a starting teacher.
 
That whole article made me a bit sad. Everything that I'm interested in and good at doing - none of it pays well.
 
The average teacher salary in my school district is close to $80,000, plus great benefits. The lowest HS salary in our district is $45,000, a starting teacher.
Uhh.. where do you live? WOW!
 
i have to wonder how accurate the data is for this study.

the one for a social work degree seems WAY off. i have'nt worked in the field for almost 7 years, but starting salaries for a degreed social worker were HUGELY higher than what they are reporting for mid career range.

just for the heck of it-i checked my former gov. employer's website to see what they were paying for newbie social workers (fresh out of college with a bachelor's degree)-their STARTING salary is over $53,000 a year, which gets bumped up 5% after 6 months, then has 3 more steps of 5% pay increases before it tops out. and that's just the entry level job-with a year of experience they can promote up to an sw2 at a much higher rate.

now, if they have an actual msw they are looking at MUCH more (it was the norm when i worked there that a new msw grad who financed their entire pre and post grad work would only end up working in children's services for 3 years b/c the salary they earned would be sufficient to pay off their student loans in their entirety so they would do so, quit and set up their own private practices).

That unfortunately is not the case in Chicago. My sister is a longtime DCFS employee. She is a rather high level manager with 17 social workers under her. She has not had a raise in SEVEN years, and her social workers do not start anywhere near $53,000, even with a master's degree. My sister has her master's in social work from the University of Chicago, plus another master's in Spanish from the University of Madrid (which comes in handy every day because a lot of her clients are spanish speaking). She is also very close to having her doctorate, she should be finished by the end of the year.

Even with her level of education and experience, she makes less than $70K a year. The government has consistently cut back on salaries, as well as employees. She does more work now for less pay, and the stress level is through the roof. Her division is in the worst parts of Chicago and the stuff she sees on a daily basis is insane! I don't know how she has stood it all these years. :sad2:

Also, I teach special ed in a fairly well off school district. Our new teachers start off at around $35K right out of college. We have some teachers in our district making upwards of $80K, but not too many.
 
The average teacher salary in my school district is close to $80,000, plus great benefits. The lowest HS salary in our district is $45,000, a starting teacher.

Which is not a livable wage in MANY areas of the country... these numbers are meaningless unless you post them with the cost of living in your area.
 
The average teacher salary in my school district is close to $80,000, plus great benefits. The lowest HS salary in our district is $45,000, a starting teacher.
It always turns to teacher pay, doesn't it?

Keep in mind that those $80,000 teaching jobs are only in a few areas of the country. Jobs in those areas of the country are harder to get, and the cost of living is higher. I'm about to begin my 18th year of teaching, and I make a tad less than your starting teachers. Also, salaries are frozen right now. Since I'm paying more for my "great benefits", I'm actually making less than I did two years ago.

The article is correct. Working with kids has never paid well because society doesn't value it. For sure, our wonderful governer doesn't value teachers.
 
The article is correct. Working with kids has never paid well because society doesn't value it. For sure, our wonderful governer doesn't value teachers.

Working with children is traditionally "women's work" and society has never valued that at all. Since most of the people who work with children are still women, wages in those areas will always be depressed.
 
It's really sad. I retired from the Air Force as an xray tech but don't want to do that anymore, so I work part time in the Infant room of a daycare. I get paid peanuts and I am taking care of INFANTS!! Parents put their most prized possession in my care every day and I get paid pennies. :confused3

Thankfully my DH has a good job and I have my Air Force retirement so I pretty much just work for vacation money, but it's sad how little I get paid.
 
It's sad, but not surprising. Traditionally female dominated professions have lousy pay.

And the data for social workers looks about right, when you compare it to the information from the Occupational Outlook Handbook. The salaries tend to vary by setting, with people who practice in school or hospital settings making a bit more than those in mental health or substance abuse work.
 
The average teacher salary in my school district is close to $80,000, plus great benefits. The lowest HS salary in our district is $45,000, a starting teacher.

After teaching middle school for 18 years I still had not reached 45K.
 
Working with children is traditionally "women's work" and society has never valued that at all. Since most of the people who work with children are still women, wages in those areas will always be depressed.

to some extent i think it's more female dominated with the younger kids. you tend to see more male teachers in the upper grades. last year as a freshman dd had only 2 female teachers out of 7 classes, this year only 1 (and it's not her gym teacher).
 
to some extent i think it's more female dominated with the younger kids. you tend to see more male teachers in the upper grades. last year as a freshman dd had only 2 female teachers out of 7 classes, this year only 1 (and it's not her gym teacher).

To some extent, yes, but even in HS, my DD had overwhelmingly more women than men and almost all the men were teaching higher level math and science classes.

Both your observation and mine are anecdotal, though. I wonder if there are statistics easily available. I'll try searching.

ETA: OK, this is all I could find with a quick search:

http://articles.chicagotribune.com/...le-teachers-chicago-public-schools-gender-gap
 

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom