Thanks everyone for your input...
First, yes, it's true....she will be driving soon but does NOT want a cell phone.

It is truly for us more than her. We will feel a little more comfortable knowing she has it if there is ever a need when driving. She does not have her own car, nor will she. (but onstar is a great suggestion for the future) She has to pay her own auto insurance ( a year up front is our rule) and she realized VERY quickly it is much more economical to be a part time driver on my car over buying one herself and being a primary driver.
Ourr DD is not scamming to try and get one...LOL...that is something our DS will try, but not her. She is just not interested, does not want ot be bothered by friends calling and bugging her over silly stuff...she's pretty low key, low maintenence. I am still trying to figure it out, but that's her way so normally we don't push her, she does have a mini Ipod...and relatives have givne her ITunes cards..she hasn't even touched those...she's very low tech other than computer graphics.
I digress tho....she'd much rather I spend on Adobe workshop programs...about $1500 for her level...but that's NOT gonna happen....so she's not going for the double gift thing...like I said, we are not even looking at it for Christmas, but since there are deals now, we started researching.
Thanks again, so far looks good to us.
Pam