Slightly rough experience Alamo

UrsulasShadow

<marquee><img src=http://photopost.wdwinfo.com/dat
Joined
Mar 15, 2005
Messages
8,457
This did not ruin my trip, by any means, but beware of the Alamo at MCO. I reserved an economy car for my stay last week. Online reservation was fine, online checkin was fine. I arrived at the Alamo stand in the garage at the airport, showed the lady directing people my check in, and she pointed me to the "Compact" row of cars, and told me to take any car in that row that was available. So, I picked out an adorable Cabriolet convertible. No lie, it was in the compact section. So, I took it.

Drove up to the check out booth, and the lady there told me I couldn't have that one, it was a convertible. I said, no kidding, but I was told to take any car in that section. She said she would have to charge me extra. I said no. So, she made me TURN AROUND (if you've ever been in that lot, you know it's one-way). She told the girl in the booth next to hers to allow me to drive the WRONG WAY back to return the car. What a pain! Cars beeping at me the whole way...I felt like an idiot.

So, I put the car back. I got all my luggage out of the car, and found another further along in the same lot. It was a small red car, 2 door, not a convertible, so I shouted to an Alamo employee at the end of the lot, IS THIS A COMPACT?? She indicated it was, and so I packed it up with my luggage yet again, and drove it to the checkout booth. No problem this time. Whew! But, on my way to this other car, I noticed another couple picking out a minivan IN THE SAME COMPACT LOT and giggling about how lucky they were. I gave them a warning, citing my experience, and told them they could try it if they wanted, but I was made to turn around and pick another. So they decided not to chance it.

Anyway, as I was driving to my villa, not 2 miles down the road, I hear a Ding Ding Ding...the fuel light was on. It was completely empty of gasoline. What a company! So, I called the phone number at the top of my rental agreement from the roadside. The nice gentleman that took my call apologized for the inconvenience, and said he'd make a note in the computer that I was to return the car empty for no charge. I took his name and thanked him, filled up my car at the nearest gas station, and thought no more about it.

Until I returned the car a week later. I pulled into the lot, and was directed to a line of cars being returned that day, and an attendant with a hand-held computer thingy. She directed me to get out of the car and hand her the keys, which she scanned. She looked at the fuel gauge, and I told her she should have a note in her computer explaining that since it was empty when I took it, I was told to return it empty. She said, "It ain't here, you're gonna have to talk to the manager over there", and started walking off with the keys. Umm, hey, lady, I need to get my luggage out of the trunk...mind if I use those keys???? Heavy sigh, handed me the keys, instructed me to leave them on the roof of the car when I was done. I know, I'm such an imposition, ain't I?

So finally I dragged my luggage over to the booth, waited my turn behind another customer, and about a half hour later got to speak with the person behind the counter...who basically says, yup, it's all here, you're all set...but you're a half-hour late, so we're going to charge you $11. Whatever. I expected the charge.

Anyway, my point is, I got this car for a very good rate...$79 for a week. But I paid for it in aggravation, because of sloppy business practices. You get what you pay for.
 
Alamo? yes, that sounds about right.

I too once had to do the backing up through the lot at MCO because they put the wrong cars in the wrong aisle. I frankly have no idea the difference between 'midsize' and 'intermediate' in American cars - if it is the aisle, I will take it....

That is why I stick with Hertz at MCO
 
My rule of travel.

Never say never.... But I said it with Alamo and HAVE NEVER looked back. National is on thin ice, the "anti service" model seems to be spreading!

I am willing to pay a little for a decent experience!
 
:eek: what if you ran out of gas on I-4?

call Alamo, i've had issues in the past & they do make an attempt to placate you (not much of one mind you ;) ) when they are obviously wrong.

new note to self - check gas gauge on rentals:rolleyes1
 

:eek: what if you ran out of gas on I-4?

call Alamo, i've had issues in the past & they do make an attempt to placate you (not much of one mind you ;) ) when they are obviously wrong.

new note to self - check gas gauge on rentals:rolleyes1

Was that what the several hundred dollar "no show" charge was? An attempt to placate me for failing to provide me with a car after an HOUR wait in thier line. (I was then told it would be a miniumum of another hour or two for my car, not by the rep who handed me the contract but by the agent waiting outside to tell us this.....):rotfl2: :rotfl2: I took the contract back inside told them to void it and took a cab!

This was not in MCO, but NEVER AGAIN!!!!!~

As to "note to self" at a GOOD rental car company they ask you as you leave "is the tank full?" Hertz ALWAYS asks me this.....
 
My rule of travel.

Never say never.... But I said it with Alamo and HAVE NEVER looked back. National is on thin ice, the "anti service" model seems to be spreading!

I am willing to pay a little for a decent experience!
I think I'm beginning to realize why they aren't a preferred provider for AAA...not that they are the be-all and end-all of good judgment, but I think next time I'll try Hertz.
 
Must have been the wife/girl friend of the Alamo employee who checked our return. Rude fellow.
 
We've had the best luck with Enterprise.

I used to think they were expensive, but when it came down to brass tacks and really comparing prices, most of the time they're within $5 to $10 of all the others for a week rental.

For the exemplary service and nice cars we've gotten, I'm very happy paying the tiny bit extra.
 
Did you really get back half an hour late or was the half hour spent waiting in line?

In the latter case they should refund the late charge.

>>> ding dong

I nitpick about the gauge being slightly short of full (shortweighting) let alone finding the car empty. Once I got out of one car and transferred my baggage to another in the (Alamo/National) aisle because the car I chose first seemed a bit short of gas.

>>> Enterprise

I have never bothered with Enterprise because of the coordination needed to have the car delivered. (Or do they now have a location very near the airport?)

Car rental hints: http://members.aol.com/ajaynejr/carrent.htm
 
Did you really get back half an hour late or was the half hour spent waiting in line?

In the latter case they should refund the late charge.
Nah, I really was about a half hour late. If it had been because of the line, I would have made a much bigger stink, and made certain they didn't charge me for it.
As for the gas, the light came on as I was driving away, so I made certain the light was on for the low fuel WELL before I pulled into the airport on return. I was sweatin' bullets, thinking I might have to push it the last few feet...:thumbsup2
 
Thanks for the heads up - what a story!

I am using Alamo out of Manchester NH the first weekend of January. Got a great deal and an upgrade but now I wonder if its worth it. I think I will do some more research.

I have had great experiences with Enterprise especially good the last two times I rented from them - I think I will start there.

TJ
 
I once rented with Alamo, returned the car, and a week later they called to ask 'where is the car?' - uh, I returned it and have a receipt from them! They charged my credit card an extra week.

My parents once spent six months fighting with Alamo re a late return in Germany - about 3 minutes, if I recall. They disputed their charge via their credit card company and Alamo still insisted on a charge back to their card. Apparently NO leeway on late returns at some Alamo locations, even by a few minutes!

On the rare occassions when Hertz mischarges me (last year I got charged for an extra day because the clock at IAD was registering the wrong time on pick up) they always reverse the charge instantly, without an argument or even discussion.

(now, if Hertz would only clean up their MUC operation - I may actually have to use a different rental car company there in future as I am tired of playing the 'no cars' game :headache: )
 
we've also had "not great" experiences with alamo at mco.
but alamo at the dolphin has been GREAT! very friendly & helpful, the valet brings your car & you give it to one upon rtn (hassle-free). the prices may be a little higher than MCO (norm about $20-30 diff after discounts/coupons), but with less gas & no tolls, it's pretty much a wash. & extremelly convenient for us as we norm stay at BWV's. :banana: (btw, the the extra driver is free b/c DH has QS).
we switch between alamo & national there ~ never a prob with either :thumbsup2
 
Alamo at the Dolphin was the main reason I am nearly leaving National.

I picked up a National car that had mechanical issues. Took it to the Dolphin. The kid behind the counter was CLUELESS about what to do. Then the computer went down while I was out getting the milage on the "broken' car. Came back in and the kid was helping another man. Had to do a manual contract. Kid writes man's name. picks up phone and calls someone "what do I put on line X" hangs up phone, does two more lines, places another call, says to customers "I don't know what I am doing" (Kid is wearing a bright yellow Alamo shirt)

Thirty minute later when the kid was still on person one, I walked out and drove the car with the waring light on all week. Personally I was hoping the engine would BLOW! IDIOTS!
 
We had issues with National with the cars. That is why I switched to Hertz and haven't had a bad rental since. It may cost more sometimes but no hassles with the car or rental.
 
In comparison to Carol's mechanical issue - I had a car from Hertz which showed that it was going to overheat a few minutes into my drive down 417. This was on a cold winter day in Orlando with frost on the ground.

Hertz sent a tow truck to my hotel to pick up the faulty vehicle and replace it with a functioning one. Very simple! Only required one call to roadside assist to have them take care of it.

(of course, some of the guests at the Comtemporary probably thought that my car was being towed because I was illegally parked, but that is another thread ;) )
 
I think it really depends on the location. At MDW for example, National and Alamo are the exact same lot, same staff, same aisles, same everything.

But I do take a little more care when renting from Alamo...at BWI we took a yellow PT Cruiser at the attendant's urging (what a piece of junk, but I digress). It had a lot of marks on the body which I got out and photographed before we left the garage, just in case.
 
Rental car agencies are just like restaurants and hotels. They will have their times where customers are displeased, but overall it's not the norm. For example, I love eating at Outback, and DH and I freqent there about 1-2 times a month. Have we had bad service? YES. Have I had a bad meal? YES. Does it happen ALL the time? NO. Can two customers experience completely different situations on the same day at the same time? YES.

My point is that every company has their problems. I just wanted to post on this thread that we had a wonderful experience renting from Alamo last week. It couldn't have been easier or more convenient. They had by far the best rate of all the agencies. We reserved full size because we wanted the space. With rental car agencies, you should book what you want, NOT hope for a free upgrade.

I think it's the luck (or lack thereof) of the draw as to if you'll have a negative experience with a rental car agency, restaurant, hotel, etc. Anyway, just wanted to post a different view...
 
Rental car agencies are just like restaurants and hotels. They will have their times where customers are displeased, but overall it's not the norm. For example, I love eating at Outback, and DH and I freqent there about 1-2 times a month. Have we had bad service? YES. Have I had a bad meal? YES. Does it happen ALL the time? NO. Can two customers experience completely different situations on the same day at the same time? YES.

My point is that every company has their problems. I just wanted to post on this thread that we had a wonderful experience renting from Alamo last week. It couldn't have been easier or more convenient. They had by far the best rate of all the agencies. We reserved full size because we wanted the space. With rental car agencies, you should book what you want, NOT hope for a free upgrade.

I think it's the luck (or lack thereof) of the draw as to if you'll have a negative experience with a rental car agency, restaurant, hotel, etc. Anyway, just wanted to post a different view...
I agree with you here. I don't rent cars often (maybe 3 times in my life), so have very little to base a full judgment on. This was a comedy of errors, and I was not expecting such a tough time of it. It all came out fine in the end, and no major harm done, except minor irritations to start off and end my vacation.

Just wanted to make one thing very clear...I was not HOPING for an upgrade. I was not LOOKING for an upgrade. I was looking for a car in the lot to which I was assigned. Service and setup was sloppy in this instance, which led to the misunderstanding of which cars were available to me. I'd heard that sometimes upgrades are given, but was not looking for one. I saw a small car, it was cute, it was in the proper lot, I thought that was the one I was supposed to take (it was even the one closest to me...I didn't go seeking it out). Just thought it was lucky that it happened to be convertible as well as compact. Was I wrong? NO. They were, for putting it in the wrong lot.

I posted this here not for sympathy. I posted it as a cautionary tale. I do not know if this level of incompetent service is prevalent in the car rental industry or not. I do want to alert people to what can go wrong, and how this particular company handled it on this particular occasion. I'm certain that many more people have good experiences with Alamo...or else I doubt they'd stay in business very long. I do know they lost my business, unless it can be shown that I would get the same treatment or worse elsewhere. If this is the standard of business industry-wide (and I doubt it is), I'll just have to learn to accept lousy treatment as my lot in life (not likely!).
 
Its fairly unusual, if only that in most locations, you can't simply pick up whatever car you want..usually you are assigned a spot. The exception is if you are a member of Emerald Aisle at National--you can pick up whatever car is in the aisle regardless of your class of service.

I was actually surprised that Alamo even let customers have that choice...but if they misplace their cars, it doesn't do much good, does it!
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom