We ate there on Monday Afternoon for lunch.
Service was leisurely, but good. Prices were slightly higher, but nothing I'd consider unreasonable for the meal we had, in a theme park, in the atmosphere we were in.
I found it very much like the Coral Reef at Living Seas at WDW.
As an example, my wife and I each had a beer, we shared "tropical Bruschetta" app., I had a combo with Jumbo Shrimp, sea scallops, and Tuna all pan-grilled with cajun seasonings, and my wife had crab cakes. We were both very pleased with the dishes, both in quality and quantity. I'm fairly picky about seafood as well.....grew up in New England, and have lived in FL and Coastal GA.
Our bill was $66.00 and change.....about what you'd expect for a similar meal in a fine dining atmosphere elsewhere, IMHO.
Now, they don't serve any sandwiches or other light fare, but the atmosphere is great, so as long as you know what you're getting, I personally don't think it's unreasonable.
YMMV.
Scott