Great thread! Ok...my picks are:
Month: April (cause thats when we can go and the weather is terrific
Route: Well, i like the Eastern better because you have one more at sea day
Port: It's on the Western...we loved Grand Cayman
Excursion: That would be the one we did on our own to Mr Sanchos Beach in Cozumel
Now, other favorites:
Show: they were all just ok for me
Game Show: WWTBAM
DrinK: Any "Drink of the Day"
Server: Gemma or Dally
Drink Server: the wonderful, amazing, fantastic Kadhir!!!