Seafood for the fish-a-phobic?

[kittycatalina65]

Trying to get all the ADRs lined up for my upcoming trip. The only request my MIL has is to have seafood one night. 2/5ths of our party are not so keen on seafood, but are willing to make do to please her.
I'm looking at menus online and hoping I can talk her into scallops and shrimp at Teppan Edo, and I know Coral Reef has steak and chicken, but do you have any other suggestions for me? How about the clambake at Cape May? Will we we eating lots of salad and bread? Thanks!

 

[KatMark]

Trying to get all the ADRs lined up for my upcoming trip. The only request my MIL has is to have seafood one night. 2/5ths of our party are not so keen on seafood, but are willing to make do to please her.
I'm looking at menus online and hoping I can talk her into scallops and shrimp at Teppan Edo, and I know Coral Reef has steak and chicken, but do you have any other suggestions for me? How about the clambake at Cape May? Will we we eating lots of salad and bread? Thanks!

Not a lot of seafood options at the Clambake--I was disappointed. Flying Fish, which I believe is two table service credits, gets great reviews for fish. We always have our fish dinner at Fulton's at Downtown Disney but, unfortunately, it is not on the dining plan.

 

[TillyMarigold]

We are big seafood eaters and are planning on Narcoossee's and Kona Café (and, believe it or not, Akershus). We also considered Flying Fish but chose Narcoosee's so we could watch Wishes.

 

[Hootch]

Disney or otherwise offer a seafood option. Is it your MIL's wish to have a wide variety of seafood choices? If so, Narcoossess's, Flying Fish or Fulton's would be the better choices. If not try The Wave whose sustainable fish is often black cod (aka butter fish or sable fish) is one of my favorites or Le Cellier which has halibut.

 

[Pumbaa_]

we like cape may - it has the clams (of course), shrimp and a fish. plus lots of stuff for the fish-a-phobic

My dh is not a fish fan and he likes it there

 

[kittycatalina65]

Thanks for the feedback so far guys.
We will be on the dining plan, and I'm thinking she'll want something like salmon, or at least a choice from several seafood options.
Still checking out menus, but now I have more to investigate!

 

[winterman]

You may want to consider the Kona Cafe. They serve a nice crab cake appy and they have a delicious entree of shrimp and scallops. That should cover 3 bases. The non-seafood eaters, I can't believe that such exist, will find plenty of entrees to chose from.

Have a great trip.