Clearly, you are pointing out a fundamental weakness of a "general" budget board, but this is still useful for all. While everyone can benefit at least a little from what others have to say, some advice will be of limited direct applicability. But the general concepts may still be helpful. We basically have enough disney visa points to give us the equivalent of "
free dining" for our upcoming 6 night stay (about 700 dollars), but that is based on us being truly blessed and fortunate to be able to have spending on an after tax basis that exceeds many other posters' after-tax total incomes (and as you note, does not include our mortgage, utilities, insurance) or car payment). And the rest of the trip just is not that much of a concern due to our situation (although we do go at off-peak times, we are not that well off.) However, that income comes from working around 60-70 hours per week (at 41), and when I was younger, routinely worked 80 plus and put most into savings, so although it may not be much help for me (or someone of similar situation) to say "use Disney Visa points for annual trip", another poster could use as a way to support an "every three year" trip, or alternatively, could suggest that another poster could consider working a few extra hours overtime or a second job