Like Granny, I doubt room reports hold much credence. Rooms are refurbished all the time, so a room that got a good report last month could be in tip top shape this month. By the same token, a room that had excellent reviews last month could have been abused and be in for repairs by the time you arrive. We always take our chances on where, and in 10 years of membership, I've really only been disappointed once on the total condition of the room, and that time they informed us that it was set for refurbishment right after we left.