We also loved the Water's Edge, but there are two other places we love a lot more.
Albergo Allegrio B&B in Wyndham, NY. Very romantic, some of the rooms/suites have fireplaces and jacuzzi's.
But our very favorite is the Mirror Lake Inn in Lake Placid. We retreat there every year for a long weekend. Spend time ambling around town, in the spa, the indoor pool, and the restaurants. We always take the same room, #439, it's incredibly gorgeous with a fireplace and private balcony. There are also rooms with jacuzzi's.
Anne