This was a one and done for me. DD15 and I had a FP in October. It was really warm that night and we were packed in like sardines. The constantly yelling next to us by CMs directing people where to go was annoying, and we had to listen to it for 45 minutes. They were telling people to only go halfway down a row. You can't tell guests that don't understand English to go halfway down the row. So when the CM would point at the row and make a motion for people to scoot down, they would go all the way down. Then the CMs would yell at them not to go all the way down, just halfway down. I love WDW CMs and I respect what they do, but this was just silly.
The show itself was underwhelming. I appreciate good music, and this was okay, but it just didn't grab me. Wishes grabs me, HEA grabs me, even the music for Illuminations and Fantasmic! grab me, but this made me want to go to sleep. The floats are pretty, but the water spray screens didn't work for me. They work in Fantasmic! because they're showing cartoons. These screen show what appears to be videos of animals, and it's really hard to see some of them. We waited for the show for over 45 minutes, and the show itself is so short! The seats are incredibly uncomfortable, and if you have to leave to use the washroom before the show begins, there's a good chance you will not get your seat back. As soon as someone would get up, the CMs would tell people to scoot together to make room for more people. Ugh.
We also had a young girl directly in front of us singing and dancing to the entire show, standing up, waving her arms all around, constantly talking to the woman sitting next to her (who she did not know), all while the girl's mother completely ignored her.
DD was bored out of her mind. Turns out, she thought it was an Avatar show and at the end she said "That had nothing to do with Avatar". I laughed a little at that and apologized that I didn't describe it to her ahead of time. I would've much rather spent my time walking around Pandora or riding KS one more time (or 3 more times).