Review of the California Grill

Forever42

The best part of Disney is the food!
Joined
Apr 6, 2004
Messages
2,350
I wanted to go someplace special to celebrate our engagement, so I asked Mike (“wherever”), and asked around, and finally decided on the California Grill. I wish we had gone back in May instead of to Artist’s Point, and I finally had another chance. It was a Thursday when I was trying to make a priority seating for that Saturday, and the only ones left were 5:30 PM and 9:40 PM. I knew the fireworks were at 10 PM, so I chose the 9:40 PM seating.

We arrived at the Contemporary resort around 8:15 PM, and went right to the second floor. We’d never been before, so hadn’t experienced the old check-in, but had no problem with this system. We overheard people checking in for 9:30 already, so we got in line. When we got to the front, we were told that there was a 30 minute wait, and for a window seat, an hour wait PAST the fireworks time. We deliberated for a minute, and decided that we would just take whichever seat we received, and that we’d go outside to the observation deck to see the fireworks. We received a buzzer, and they asked if we wanted to go upstairs to wait, and we did, so we were escorted up to the 15 th floor.

When we arrived upstairs, it was around 8:20, and it was very crowded and noisy. There wasn’t much of a romance or relaxing factor in the beginning with how loud it was. All of the seats at the bar and in the lounge area were taken, with many people standing. After a few minutes of not being able to find a seat, we went to the observation deck. The view is beautiful, and I’m glad we were able to look around before it was completely dark. After I took some pictures, we went back inside. As soon as some people got up to leave their table in the lounge, I grabbed it. The lounge consists of quite a few tables in the center of the restaurant, with tables, and some are against the windows. We saw many people sharing appetizers and having drinks before their meals. I believe I even saw some people eating complete meals.

The people before us had left the menu behind, and Mike and I decided to split a flatbread while we were waiting. Well, we waited for someone to come and take a drink order from us. And waited. And waited. And waited. Mike finally got up and asked someone at the desk, and he was told someone would be with us shortly. Well, shortly ended up being an HOUR after we sat down, because one of the servers thought that our table was in someone else’s area, and it was actually her area. We were steaming by this point, not that we had waited this long for a table in the restaurant, but that no one had even asked if we had been helped. Mike had even asked at the bar, and they told him that he had to wait for someone to come by to take our order.

So finally, a server came around and took our order. I asked for a mojito, and they said they didn’t make them, so I asked for a water instead. Mike asked for a diet Coke, and was told it would be complimentary. We never had a chance to ask for a flatbread, because at that time, our buzzer went off. We went up to the front, and then we were escorted to our table.

The location of our table just about made up for it. We were actually given a window seat, and even though there was a small window support in the middle of our view, we had a great view of the castle and Space Mountain, where we knew the fireworks would be going off. Our server, Joanna, came by and said that we probably were seated there because we were celebrating. How exciting! For our drinks, Mike stuck with his diet Coke, and I was still perusing the wine list. We did still want to start with a flatbread, so we chose the mango chicken barbecue flatbread ($9.25). It had roasted chicken, mango barbecue sauce, Monterey jack cheese, and mango avocado salsa. It actually came out very quickly, even though it was late and we had just sat down. It was oval shaped, with a crisp crust. There was a perfect amount of toppings, and it was just perfect. The barbecue sauce was slightly sweet and very flavorful, and the mango avocado salsa was wonderful on top. It might sound a little odd, but everything went very well together.

I looked over the wine list, and was in the mood for a chardonnay, so I asked Joanna what she thought about the Flora Springs chardonnay ($9.75). She said that it was right in the middle between buttery and oaky, and said that she could give me a taste before I decided. If I didn’t like that, she’d try something else. Luckily, the one I picked first, the Flora Springs, was wonderful. I definitely recommend it.

I was curious about the sushi at the California Grill, since I had heard so many raves about it. Joanna told me that the tempura soft shell crab roll came with the legs, when I asked about it, and I definitely declined. She suggested the California roll ($17.00) instead, and I asked if I could get the spicy sauces with it, as well. Mike ordered the mushroom soup ($8.25) at my suggestion. The sushi was very good, but it wasn’t the best I’d ever had. It may have been different if I’d ordered sashimi instead, but the crab was still of high quality. I loved the sauces that came with it, though. Along with soy sauce and spicy teriyaki, it also came with a sriricha sauce, which is a very spicy Thai chili puree . I had just been reading about it in Cooking Light magazine, and was interested in trying it. Both of the spicy sauces went great with the sushi (a little unorthodox, but it tasted good!). Mike’s mushroom soup was good, but nothing like the roasted Portobello soup at Artist’s Point. It really paled in comparison to the rich, hearty soup at Artist’s Point. It actually was a very good soup at the California Grill, though, with a deep, creamy mushroom flavor and roasted mushrooms on top.

While we were still in the middle of our first course, the lights dimmed, the music was piped in, and the fireworks started. It was so beautiful from on top of the Contemporary that I started to tear up. It was much better from this high up than from the fourth floor observation deck. I still love the view from the Polynesian, though, because the fireworks are right behind the castle.

For our entrees, I knew a long time ago what I’d order – the pork tenderloin ($21.75). I recommended to Mike that he order the oak fired beef tenderloin ($34.50), but he didn’t need any prodding for that. Joanna highly recommended both, as well. Interestingly enough, we had been told before that all service shuts down during the fireworks, but our entrees were brought out then. We didn’t mind, though. Once fireworks were over, we settled down to our entrees, as I took pictures. (Joanna just laughed when she saw me taking pictures – it’s a common response. That, and bewilderment.) Mike’s filet was brought without a steak knife, and he said that they must think highly of themselves. Believe it or not, he could cut the steak with his butter knife. He said that it was one of the best steaks he’s ever had, rivaling the one at Le Cellier. I think that he liked the potatoes even more than the steak, though, and I had to agree. It was a three cheese potato gratin, and it was just amazing, rich and full of flavor. I had asked for the recipe, but I think Joanna forgot to bring it. Also on the side were crisp-tender green beans, and Mike loved the texture and how fresh they tasted.

My pork tenderloin was also wonderful. It didn’t come with a steak knife, either, and could practically be cut with a fork. It was very tender and juicy, and cooked just a touch past medium well. It’s definitely one of the best pork dishes I’ve had, right up there with the pork at the Disney Dining Experience Polynesian luncheon. It was served over creamy polenta, which had an incredibly silky texture. Mike even liked it, and he doesn’t like polenta. On top of the pork were sautéed cremini mushrooms and crispy sage leaves. I love it when herbs are fried as a garnish, and these were delicious with the pork. The whole dish went together so well, and I can see why it’s been on the menu for so long – it’s perfect.

While we were eating, Joanna brought by the dessert menus, because if we wanted the Valrhona chocolate cake ($9.50), it would take 20 minutes to prepare. Of course, that’s one of the ones I wanted to order. We weren’t sure what else, and though I also wanted to try the Valrhona torte, Joanna said that it would be too much chocolate. She said the mango crème brulee was definitely only for mango lovers. We debated on the sorbet, but finally I decided on the cheese plate ($9.75). I considered ordering a dessert wine, but didn’t see anything I wanted. I did see the Grand Marnier 100 and 150 on the menu, and debated it for a second, but both of them were a bit expensive ($20 and $29). The Valrhona cake came with white chocolate ice cream and a chocolate drizzle. Mike’s face froze when he tried the ice cream – it was absolutely fantastic. It had such a rich white chocolate flavor, which surprised us because of how lightly flavored white chocolate ice cream can be. The chocolate cake didn’t disappoint, either. I took the first bite, and the chocolate came oozing out. It was real chocolate lava cake, with an incredibly fudgy flavor. This was truly a magnificent dessert, which might sound a bit over the top, but it’s just that wonderful. The cheese plate I had was the first dessert cheese plate I ever had, and it was an interesting change. Since Mike isn’t the cheese fan that I am, I let him have the majority of the chocolate cake. The cheese plate had a parmesan crisp, cheddar flan, Hereford hop, and a cheese with a blue rind. The parmesan crisp was a cup made out of parmesan cheese, and it held the cheddar flan. The flan had a great cheddar flavor, and not too sharp. The cheese with a rind had a herbal fermented rind, which was a bit too strong for me, so I ate around it. I really enjoyed the Hereford hop, which is a British cheese. The cheddar flan spread nicely on the small, dense pieces of nut bread that accompanied this plate. While I did enjoy the cheese plate, it was overshadowed by the Valrhona cake, so it might have taken away from some of my enjoyment.

By the end of dessert, we were definitely ready to go home, as it’d been a long day. The check was brought out quickly, and we paid and walked out. Mike stopped by the restroom, and one of the lounge servers apologized to us about our wait in the beginning (interestingly, the woman who ignored us never apologized, or even said anything to us), and asked how our meals were. Mike pulled me back towards the restrooms after we chatted, because he wanted to show me all of the pictures and articles about the restaurant lining the walls – they are definitely written about quite often!

Our dinner here was excellent, overall. The food was fantastic (if a bit pricey!), and service in the restaurant area was impeccable. If we hadn’t been so tired, we would have tried to find a manager regarding the lounge area. It honestly did take away from the experience we had, somewhat. But our seat was perfect, and the view of the fireworks was wonderful. Even if you don’t have a view of the fireworks, you are still allowed to get up and walk out to the observation deck, and I did see quite a few people standing up. The view, fireworks or no fireworks, was beautiful and really brings in a lot of Disney magic. I saw many people in shorts (including us), and many people in fancier clothes. I honestly didn’t feel bad in shorts and a shirt. This was another one of our most memorable dining experiences, and also one of our favorites. I definitely recommend it for a special occasion, or even just a night out without the kids.

Photo gallery
 
I always love the detail in your reviews. We have ressies for the California Grill in Sept. and can't wait, especially after your wonderful descriptions. Keep them coming!
 
thanks for the review. i love that place, although i agree it can be much too loud for the price of the dinner.
the filet was the best meal i've ever had (next to anyone mom cooks when i visit). and the valhora cake, especially the white chocolate ice cream, is just amazing.
thanks for the pics. it brought back some great memories, and made me want my counter to hit zero again even sooner.
 

Wow! A review AND pictures! Thank you so much for posting. :teeth:
 
Thanks for the detailed report.

I'd love to have a piece of the chocolate cake right now.
 
Excellent review ~ Thanx for sharing.
 
Another excellent review!! CG will be our first nite dinner in October.
It appears as though that lounge/bar area continues to be a problem, even with the new entrance procedure. It sounds like they continue to let bar/lounge customers up to the 15th floor w/o being sure there are any seats at the bar, or lounge tables available(?)
Thanks for including how you (and others) were dressed:D
 
Originally posted by Uncleromulus
Another excellent review!! CG will be our first nite dinner in October.
It appears as though that lounge/bar area continues to be a problem, even with the new entrance procedure. It sounds like they continue to let bar/lounge customers up to the 15th floor w/o being sure there are any seats at the bar, or lounge tables available(?)
Thanks for including how you (and others) were dressed:D

Thank you! I was thinking of you when I ordered the pork tenderloin.

Yes, even though someone had just called down saying that it was overcrowded and there were no seats anywhere available, they let us and others go right up. Just a little frustrating, to say the least.

And about the dress, I know that a lot of people have been asking lately. Mike felt a little odd at first in his shorts, but I'd say the majority of the people there were in business casual or less.
 
Thank you so much for all of your restaurant reviews! You do a first rate job of sharing with us all.
 
That pork certainly is good--and despite wanting to try something else, no doubt I'll wind up ordering it again in Oct.
When you go to Citrico's in Oct. (we'll be there ourselves on Oct. 6) do try their Honey/Paprika Pork tenderloin. Just about as good as CG.
 
Thanks again for another great dinning review. I had the pork tenderloin last Dec. and it was fantastic, I can't wait to order it again on our next trip.

Congradulations on your engagement.
 
Originally posted by Uncleromulus
That pork certainly is good--and despite wanting to try something else, no doubt I'll wind up ordering it again in Oct.
When you go to Citrico's in Oct. (we'll be there ourselves on Oct. 6) do try their Honey/Paprika Pork tenderloin. Just about as good as CG.

Ooh, that does sound good. We'll probably be doing it before MNSSHP, and I'm not sure which night we're doing it. Not Oct 6, though.
 
hi, thanks for the great review! believe it or not, my question is not about the food, but "wishes"! you mentioned that the view was much better from the cg than the 4th fl. is the 4th fl not so good? too many people in front of you? do you see all the fireworks and is the music piped in? thanks
 
thanks for the review and the photos we are looking forward to dinning here on our next trip so lucky to live so close ...Mike
 
THANKS!

This is one place we haven't been to yet, but I'm ALWAYS looking for a great filet, so we may just splurge the next time we're down!
 
Every time I read such a detailed review like yours, I want to change my plans. I had intended for my special night with my DH to be at Jiko because I thought the savannah at night sounded romantic but this made me well up just reading it. Jiko or California Grill? Maybe that should be my next post! Thanks for posting guys and I'm sorry the lounge nearly spoiled what sounds like an incredible night.

Claire.
 














Save Up to 30% on Rooms at Walt Disney World!

Save up to 30% on rooms at select Disney Resorts Collection hotels when you stay 5 consecutive nights or longer in late summer and early fall. Plus, enjoy other savings for shorter stays.This offer is valid for stays most nights from August 1 to October 11, 2025.
CLICK HERE













DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top