Review--ASMu, CSR and Poly LV Concierge

eller

DIS Veteran
Joined
Oct 24, 2000
Messages
8,391
You've heard of park hopping; well, we hotel hopped this trip!

We had a wonderful trip. Here are the hotel highlites.

ASMu--Loved it! Two nights was not enough. We paid extra for perfered veiw and I'm very glad we did. The main pool was great. Mousekeeping did a fine job. We didn't eat at the food court. (Did and Movies and didn't like it.) Didn't use the laundry fasilities (oh, darn!). Bus service and check in were effecient.

CSR--Loved it! The themeing here is great, but I can see why people would say it's spread out. I requested (and got) building 9A and the family thought it was a bit of a walk. DD12 said that the pool was too far away. The busses were close and that was good! Busses and checkin were efficient. Mousekeeping even left a towel duck. Very cute!

Polynesian LV concierge--Prior to the trip DH would say, "We can always switch [to AKL], after I would complain about the pre-itinerary service or read a post that wasn't favorable. Pre-itinerary service was not as (good) as I expected. Slow returns on email and called after saying not to because the kids don't know. However, Matthew did send a box with flower and shell lei's and card from Mickey and Minnie to the kids saying, "See you real soon!" We used these as part of the gift to tell the kids their Christmas presant was to go to Disney.

Room--just as we remembered, except only one sink (we knew that though, so no shock). Beds were comportable. I requested 3rd floor, but got 1st. We took it, just a few doors down from the concierge check in desks. (I loved being close to the lounge.) Was LV worth it? I'm still not sure, but I loved walking out on the patio in my PJs to watch the fireworks! The only things that DH and I noticed that indicated that the room was in need of refurbishment was two rips in the carpet.

CMs--Most were nice, but not as welcoming as we felt at AKL and we thought some were standoffish (if that's a word) there. The last day we met the nicest CM, and she had transfered over from somewhere else and this was her first day! Phil was great at shipping our "Santa" stuff home.

Lounge--The view is great! Chef Dick's food is wonderful. A few things that we felt were missing were cloth napkins and watermellon at breakfast. Watermellon is what DS4 eats for breakfast, so we noticed it not being there. The uncrustables were a new treat for DS4, so I guess it evened out.

Bus service was not the best, but that's not why you stay there.

Mousekeeping left a wonderful 100 years of magic one night, but that was it as far as towel sculpting.

Would we stay at any of these again? ASMu--yes, the price is right. (Rooms are small in compairison to moderates and deluxes.)

CSR--would love too, but don't think we will. Family of five is a better fit in a deluxe or two rooms at All Stars.

Poly--maybe, maybe not. It's a wonderful hotel, but loved AKL more.

Happy to answer any questions.

Lori
 
Welcome home, Lori! Thanks for the candid review. I'm eager to try AKL Concierge one of these days--that is still one I haven't experienced. It's sounds like the AKL left a good impression on you. After this trip, which would you pick again--Polynesian or AKL? Thanks!

:)
 
I'd stay at AKL in a heartbeat!

It is, however, our goal to stay at all Disney resorts. AKL may not make the top of the list for a while because of this. We want to stay at another MK resort, so next trip we are going to try to stay at either the CR or WL. And an Epcot resort. Being a family of 5 WL is too small. We are thinking of asking my MIL to come with us and that word give us two rooms at WL, and a deluxe room at BWI.

It all depends on what discounts come out! If AKL twp rooms concierge is less than BWI deluxe concierge, then we would stay at AKL.

The Poly is tropical and a wonderul place to relax. The pool slide is great! I forgot to mention that; best slide I've been on.

AKL is relaxing in a very different way--cozy! The concierge lounge lends itself better to people mingling rather than forming a line, as we seemed forced to ain the Poly lounge.

I've desided that no bathroom is good for doing makeup. AKL is no darker in that respect.

I hope in all my rambling that I've answered your question with the whys.

Atmosephere is everything and I think it is all about what you like.

Lori
 

Thanks, Lori! Staying at a different Disney resort has always been my goal, too. I've done every resort except the Value resorts, CS and AKL. I really need to make it a point to try these out at some point. I've visited each of them but now I just need to stay there. That is the best way for me to get the true "feel" for them.

Thanks again for the review! :)
 
Hi Lori,
Can you e-mail me? I have some questions for you about AKL. Sorry I didn't get to see you again before we left...I did see your older daughter in the lounge one evening and she said you were drying your hair. Maybe we'll meet up again sometime!

Rita
 
Thanks Lori! I've been looking for some recent reviews of ASMu, since we will be there in 38 days! Glad to hear that you enjoyed it!
 
I wish I had taken a picture of the building we were in. Hind sight, you know! We will stay there again, but get two rooms for the five of us. Double beds are just too small for DH and me and I don't like sleeping with the kids, they wiggle! Baby will be too old next trip anyway.

My MIL stayed in Music in September, but didn't like it. When I asked you why, she said that it was because of the line green paint. So be prepared; I didn't mind though. It's only on the out side of the building.

Lori
 















Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE







New Posts







DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top