Rethinking my ADRS...again

[irisbud]

Okay, this is what we have so far as of this moment, actually reserved:

Sunday: (arrival day) Liberty Tree Tavern, 2:00 PM
Monday: Shula's 5:00 PM
Tuesday: Boma 5:00 PM
Wednesday: Le Cellier 1:00 PM
Thurday: (Departure day) No ADRs, but do not have to leave on DME until 4:00

We are staying Sun&Mon at GF, Tues&Wed at AKL

Here is my question / dilemma:

My BF didn't want to plan anything at first, but then became somewhat interested (though not in a freakish, obsessive way like me). After looking through UG, the two restaurants he was most interested in were Le Cellier and Shula's (he is a meat and potatoes man). I had concierge book reservations for each of these, but I would really rather do V&A's than Shula's. I have eaten at Shula's before and I really liked it so I have no problem with eating there again, I just think it would be PERFECT to eat at V&A's while we are staying at GF RPC .
Soooo... if I change our reservations and just don't tell will he be dissappointed with the food? He isn't into any kind of pretentiousness, and I'm afraid he would think the food too snobby. Also, everything looks delicious, but will I like it? I love to try new things, but I am a picky eater and I have some food allergies.
There you have it. Opinions please: Shula's or V&A's?

 

[bsmcneil]

shula's. maybe he can do V&A some other time (you can ease him into it)?

 

[TimeforMe]

I haven't eaten at Shula's, but it seems like something you can get at any very good steakhouse. V&A's, on the other hand, is very special. We've eaten at many fine restaurants and this is definitely one of our most memorable. The food is awesome--you'll love it.

 

[irisbud]

TimeforMe, this is along the lines of what I was thinking. When my dad and I ate at Shula's on our last trip, we enjoyed it but were not totally blown away. You are correct, it is similar to any really good steakhouse. I just don't know if V&A's would be too over the top for him...

I really want to wear my pretty dress!

 

[TimeforMe]

I really want to wear my pretty dress!

Awww, then you should definitely go to V&A's and wear your pretty dress.! You only live once.

Just an aside, they are very, very helpful in accomodating any food restrictions, etc. I have a friend (and her dh) who are strict vegetarians and they went there and LOVED it. She still talks about it. I would call ahead and let them know your concerns. I can't believe anyone would not enjoy eating there(until the bill comes at least )--the food is to die for and a very, very special experience.

You don't mention when you're going, but let us know when you decide. Have fun!

 

[irisbud]

Well, AKL IPO booked V&A's for us for December 4th at 6:00. I can't wait! Only 4 1/2 months to wait now...