At Disney, we tend to enjoy the experience more than the food. As such, our places that rarely disappoint (they all have had a disappointment now and then) are Sci-Fi Dine In Theater, Via Napoli, Jiko, Tiffins, and San Angel Inn.
Often someone will say to us "Eww... (insert restaurant here) is terrible! We didn't like it at all!" to which I say "Well, we really enjoy it!"