Ok so I'll summarize the points people asked me to look for:
Safety: I felt 100% safe. They had a security guard at the front door at all hours which I liked. We never had issues with people trying to enter our room (yes, this has happened at other places, thankfully, the door was locked).
The safe was HUGE and easily fit our wallets, laptop, smart phones, documents, purse, with room to spare. Plus, it's not a key lock but a code you enter each time (so you can change it as often as you want and the staff don't have a way of knowing it, unlike if you accidentally leave a safe key lying around).
I left tips (in clearly marked envelopes on the table) and the staff didn't take them. They moved them and cleaned around them, but never took them any night. I appreciate that and it makes me feel safe that they wouldn't even consider taking what doesn't belongs to them (we still used the safe though).
Cleanliness: The room was clean. Our socks stayed white. The showerhead was a little weak, but the shower was clean with no mould. Our linens were fresh each day (unless we didn't use them) and I never had any issues with cleanliness.
Walk/Distance: At the start of the trip, we didn't feel the walk was long. It's not unreasonable at all. After running the race... It felt a little too long but neither of us could stand so, that's our own fault.
It took us about 10 minutes or less depending on traffic lights. The ART (
route 6) stops right outside the door though and Red Lion is the last pick up before the parks and last drop off from the parks. We used this after the race for ease on our feet.
I would say the walk may be far for littler guests, though. But I felt we were a lot closer than many of the hotels with the exception of the couple directly across the way. I'd rather the walk since I felt this hotel offered a lot in exchange.
Food: Some may recall I didn't plan to eat here. Well we got there way early (like 1:30 pm local time) and checked in. When we went to our room, it wasn't ready so we came back down and they apologized profusely (I didn't really care since we were so early) but they gave us vouchers for free breakfast to make ammends (sweet!) and stored our luggage securely while we went out.
Honestly, I heard terrible things about the breakfast and expected the worst. I was beyond shocked to find it otherwise. I went up for 3 or more helpings of food. It was hot, it was clean, and I had no complaints at all. I loved the hashbrowns, sausage rounds, and french toast. I don't like bacon, so I didn't try that. I generally am violently ill from eggs but these didn't bother me at all. There was tons of fresh fruit (cut and whole), yogurt, hot oatmeal, cold cereal, and a wide selection of breads/bagels. They even had something that would cook your pancakes right for you there (as well as some already made with the hot food).
Drink-wise, coffee/tea/fruit juice/hot chocolate were available at the buffet (and cold milk for cereal) as well the server brought me a glass of milk. All of that was included. I'm not sure if my glass being free was due to the voucher or not, though.
We got the meal for free, but it is normally 9.95. I would say it's a high end continental breakfast and given that it's all you can eat (and we saw people take whole fruit for the road without issue, not sure if they were allowed though) I don't think 9.95 is unreasonable, especially given the cost of eating most places in and around Disneyland. I'd pay 9.95 here in my city for a buffet so

.
Pool: We went down and looked at the pool but never used it. It's not too big, not too small. It looked clean and there was an abundance of pool toys available for use. The wall said the max number of people was 140, but that seems a bit much to me. There is some very nice lounging areas around the pool with nice furniture and firepits that are turned on at night. The hours for the pool weren't bad (either 5 or 7 am until 10 pm). It looked like music could be piped out there from the restaurant and there is (normally open) patio doors from the restaurant (and through it the main lobby/store) to the pool area. The grab-n-go area of the main lobby had pool toys and floaties for sale as well.
Bed: The bed we had was a king bed. At home we have a pillow top no-disturb matress so ours is more firm than most. I found the matress at Red Lion to be a little futon-like: flat and smushy. It wasn't bad at all and we had no problem sleeping on it, but we tend to prefer matresses with more form and firmness.
Thoughts:
Cons (shorter list):
- The fridge did not stay cold, only cool, and turned off every couple hours. If we'd been staying there for any longer length of stay or reliably needed the fridge, we'd have asked about it. Also, it had a very bad aroma, but was thankfully behind a cupboard so you only smelt it when you used it.
- The bathroom needs a fan and a door that is the right size. They have a sliding door for the bathroom (the theming is great so I liked that) but it was about 0.5-1 inch too small so there was always a small opening on either side where someone might catch a glimpse of something they wish they hadn't. Not an issue for us, but if you have many adults sharing a room, or something.
- We found 1 bug, not a bed bug, not a cockroach, and easily killed by DBF, but given a previous poster mentioned it, we did find one our first night and that was it.
- Possibly long walk depending on feet and size, but not unreasonable.
- The water pressure was weak in the shower.
- Staff can be clueless sometimes, but they are definitely helpful and willing to try.
Pros:
- The theming and style of the room is great! DBF and I loved it. It didn't feel dated or floral. It felt modern and slick.
- The fireworks view was great (we were on floor 6). We could watch them lying in bed. We also got great landscape views with the mountains and sunsets.
- The tv didn't always come in clear but it was big and easy to see. The alarm clock has a doc for iPods and nature sounds so we really liked that.
- Free wifi and cabled internet made things a breeze for setting up things with family back home. When it didn't work, we'd call the front desk and they already had someone fixing it. It was usually up again in less than 5 minutes and this only happened 2 times.
- We had no sound issues minus the earlier mentioned hammering which the front desk remedied shortly after we called about it. We could hear the fire works a little bit but most nights it was so quiet we were able to sleep right through it.
- The safe was best one I've ever had and the one I've felt the most safe using. No chance of a staff member using a misplaced key to access it and ample space for even large-sized valuables (it was about the size of a microwave).
- The microwave worked well as well. The sink in the bathroom had no delay in hot water (sometimes I find it can take a while) and had good flow so you weren't washing forever (I loved the sink!). The Bath and Body Works supplies were nice, and quickly replaced as needed. It was comforting to see a brand I knew wouldn't irritate my skin.
- The Disneyland Express drops and picks up right outside the door (at the ART) station. We only had to be out there for a total of 1.5 minutes to get picked up and be on our way. No hassle, no issue, no walk.
- The grab-n-go had lots of quick to go food, from packaged bagels to hand-made sandwiches, cold drinks and hot drinks, and all sorts of things a traveller might need (maps, pool stuff, sunscreen). It was open 24 hours a day along with the front desk, and there was a full fledged store open during normal hours.
- There was a data station in the front lobby for travellers to hook up devices and use the wifi if they were waiting for something, as well as a touch screen large T.V. with access to forecasts and other useful travel details as well as the potential to use it to book shuttles and other necessities. Very handy for those without a smart phone.
I think that's it for now. If I think of anything else or anyone has any questions, let me know!

for Red Lion!