Of the places I've actually stayed:
Port Orleans French Quarter (best combo of price/location/resort theme-atmoshere boat to DTD)
Beach Club (best atmosphere, great location, loved the theme)
All Star Music (best price per night and the least over the top themed of the values which is a plus for me)
Art of Animation (better price than Mod but I didn't like the over the top giant icon theme/atmosphere)
Places I'd like to stay:
Wilderness Lodge (grew up camping and loved statepark/lodge theme, boat to MK)
Port Orleans Riverside (love the look of the place)
Poly (location, monorail and theme and to be honest Kona Cafe was faboo!)
Animal Kingdom Lodge (ANIMALS off your balcony)