Really tough call. I love both. And for me atmosphere is tied to both. Love the entertainment at Raglan and love sitting outside and watching the boats at Boathouse. I think it would come down to what I was in the mood for. Per dining plan guidelines, Boathouse is a signature and I’d say they do have more “upscale” offerings — but also have sandwiches, burgers etc. Raglan is a true Irish pub. The shepherd’s pie is divine. I don’t think you can go wrong!