Q, would you be offended? Update pg 3

Rowena

DIS Veteran
Joined
Dec 6, 2004
Messages
1,129
My dad signed up for these joke text messages sent to his phone, which he shares. He just sent me one..

Q: Did you hear about the moron who tried to speak his mind? A: He was speechless.

Now, um, my DD, his granddaughter is non-verbal autistic. She is "speechless".

Would you take offense at this?
 
I'm sure your dad wasn't thinking when he forwarded it.

I had some idiot forward me a message that I thought was inappropriate. Comes to our home e-mail and meant for hubby but it is the joint e-mail account. I was livid for receiving two e-mails that were quite ignorant...and I told the guy so. I still get e-mails, but no longer do I receive the ones on that topic.

You might just let your dad know the inappropriateness of it and to not send them to you anymore. If he continues to send them, then yes I would be offended.
 

I wouldn't. I do not believe that it was intended; however, people should be more sensitive and careful by what they send out (many do not even read them themselves).

Don't think of it, again.
 
No. It's not a joke about autistic children. If you don't read between the lines on the joke and think of it as a 'joke', then it's not offensive IMHO.

But that's me. Not a lot offends me.
 
I already replied with

"Ouch, you do realize that years ago, Katie could have easily been diagnosed as a moron. That was a bit offensive."

I didn't blow it out of proportion, but that particular joke did leave a slimy taste in my mouth. Kind of the same way "short bus" jokes do. :confused3
 
My vote is for highly insensitive, given the circumstances.

I think your reply was perfect.
 
I wouldn't be offended. It was a jab at morons, not non-verbal people.

It reminds me of something that happened to me many years ago. My sons grandmother had bought him a package of nursery rhyme bibs. One of the bibs was of 3 Blind Mice. My son had recently diagnosed as visually impaired. His grandmother was distraught when she realized what had happened. I knew she meant nothing by it though, so all was well.
 
Actually, I think the opposite is in order here. I would be happy.

To me it shows that your dad has so fully accepted your daughter that her disAbilities aren't first and foremost in his mind. She is just his granddaughter - not his non-verbal granddaughter.

He probably sent it without even thinking. And this is a good thing. Insensitive yes, but still a good thing. :grouphug:
 
Rowena said:
"Ouch, you do realize that years ago, Katie could have easily been diagnosed as a moron. That was a bit offensive."

I didn't blow it out of proportion, but that particular joke did leave a slimy tatse in my mouth. Kind of the same way "short bus" jokes do. :confused3

I would be more offended by a "diagnosis" of "moron", since I can't imagine that's a medical term any doctor would use.

I don't think you blew it out of proportion, BTW. You were offended and you told your dad so. I understand where you're coming from. :)
 
Nana Annie said:
Actually, I think the opposite is in order here. I would be happy.

To me it shows that your dad has so fully accepted your daughter that her disAbilities aren't first and foremost in his mind. She is just his granddaughter - not his non-verbal granddaughter.

He probably sent it without even thinking. And this is a good thing. Insensitive yes, but still a good thing. :grouphug:
::yes::
 
As the sister of a deaf, blind, and mute brother I have heard every Helen Keller joke in the book. Many told by immediate family members. And I despite the fact that I'll probably burn for it, I have laughed at all of them!
 
Actually, I am not sure that's it bubie2.5 and Nana Annie. I wish it were, he visited us, was the first time in 4 years we'd all seen each other. He agreed to stop sending dolls but thinks the best course of action "is to pretend there's nothing wrong"...
Yes, he really told me that.


And, the trouble with the word "moron" was it WAS a medical term, used around up to the 1930's to describe those afflicted with mild mental retardation, and autism was often lumped in with it back then. (I read to much on the net, I guess.)

"Idiot indicated the greatest degree of mental deficiency, where the mental age is 2 years or less, and the person cannot guard himself against common physical dangers. The term was gradually replaced by the term profound mental retardation.
Imbecile indicated a mental deficiency less extreme than idiocy and not necessarily inherited. It is now usually subdivided into two categories, known as severe mental retardation and moderate mental retardation.
Moron was defined by the American Association for the Study of the Feeble-Minded in 1910, following work by Henry H. Goddard, as the term for an adult with a mental age between eight and twelve; mild mental retardation is now the term for this condition. Alternative definitions of these terms based on IQ were also used. " from here as one example.
 
Having been the mother of two special needs sons, I wouldn't have been offended. I think sometimes us parents can be a little over-sensitive when it comes to things just like this. It's something you eventually get over! Took me a while, but I did. I'm sure your dad will cringe and feel really bad after he reads the email you sent him regarding the joke. I would follow it up with something that that might make him feel a little better. I'm sure he's not an insensitive person and didn't think of anything other than passing on his joke of the day.
 
Since you obviously were offended, and have already responded as such to your father, it is kind of pointless to ask us now! FWIW, it wouldn't offend me either.
 
Nope. I wouldn't find it offensive. I would just take the joke in the spirit it was intended - sort of like those bumper stickers that say, "Don't bother giving me a piece of your mind. You haven't got it to spare."

:rotfl:

But, then, not much offends me. :confused3
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom