Goofy4Tink, The categories have changed at POR that that is what is causing the confusion. If it were just waterview vs standard view I'd completely agree with you. Here are the new categories:
Standard View- These rooms offer views of the Resort hotel, landscaping, courtyard, garden or bayou.
Water View- These rooms offer views of the riverfront or courtyard pool.
Preferred Room- These rooms offer close proximity to the registration building, dining, transportation and Resort amenities.
River View Rooms- These rooms offer views of the riverfront
Now that Preferred room is the kicker. There's lot of people who'll pay for a preferred location, myself included. However, What consititues "close proximity" some have suggested that all of the river facing rooms of the mansions are "close proximity" but I'll tell you, I was not really thrilled with the walk to and from Partierre Place when I stayed there. I "preferred" Magnolia Terrace which was exactly where I wanted to be.
If I pay for a "preferred" room, I like to be able to either choose the area that I want or know the areas that fall into that category so I can make an informed decision.