Thank you all
so much for your responses!
I guess that's what I'm worried about, that the resort and particularly the Alligator Bayou section would feel woodsy like WL.
Lots of recommendations for the Magnolia Bend rooms, and truthfully those buildings and rooms appeal to me more, from what I've seen in pictures. But I know POR is very spread out, and I'm afraid Magnolia Bend would have me walking a long way to the pool and the food court. I don't mind logging a lot of miles at Disney, but I recently stayed at AoA in a Cars building that was furthest from the main building. The 5-minute walk to refill mugs got very old very fast, simply because I had to do it so many times a day. That's why I was aiming for a preferred room in AB.
Decisions, decisions! Any more info and opinions are appreciated.