AS Sports is in a better location than POP in my family's opinion. Advantages of POP are the theme and not having to share busses. Plus I think POP is much prettier than All Star. But for location purposes and if you don't really care about theme, All Star Sports is the way to go. Sports is also the first to be picked up/dropped off on the all star bus loop if I remember right anyway. Honestly, if you're staying value and the hotel atmosphere isn't that important to you, I'd go All Star. But I much preferred staying in Pop because of the theme. Although I'm not the one spending the money on the trip yet