We stayed there 9/18-9/23 for part of our honeymoon.
The good:
Room size! It's nice to have those huge rooms. And we both are very sensitive to smells, and mold is one of my wife's asthma triggers. Neither one of us had any sort of problem with mold.
The restaurants. Ohanas was DELICIOUS, albeit somewhat expensive. Neither one of us ate $25 worth, but it was delicious, and the service was wonderful. We had stayed at the Beach Club the 5 nights prior, and NOT having a convenient counter service place was a pain in the neck. Captain Cook's was WONDERFUL for a quick bite to eat, as well as for the refillable mugs.
The monorail. How convenient to just hop the monorail and get to the Magic Kingdom, or WALK to the TTC to take the monorail to Epcot. The location of the Polynesian, in my opinion, is the best of the Magic Kingdom resorts.
The pool. We loved the zero depth entry, as well as the volcano! I didn't get a chance to go down the slide, but I REALLY wanted to!

The quiet pool was closed, so I can't say much about that.
The landscaping. It's SO pretty. The bamboo, the foliage...it's just wonderful. There's nothing better than just sitting in a lounge area of the Great Ceremonial House and just enjoying the plants and the waterfall.
Cast members! Some of the cast members were so wonderful, and helpful! Shirley at the Polynesian Princess conversed with us each time we picked up a package. She had been affected by the hurricanes and her daughter was worried. We asked her how that was coming along, and she asked us how we were enjoying our honeymoon. Jane at Captain Cook's was friendly, and also struck up some conversation when we saw her!
The bad:
Cast members. I listed this in both because as great as some cast members were, others were downright rude. Nancy, who checked us in, was one of the rude ones. She didn't acknowledge us when we were waiting to check in and we and she were the ONLY ones there!!!!! Housekeeping also gave us issues when we asked to have the sheets changed. We had some of those little bugs that others have seen, and we asked ONCE to have the sheets changed and got attitude.
Location. To get to other places around property, it was pretty far removed from everything else. Seeing the castle is great, but I much prefer to be in a central location, and I found the Epcot resorts area much more central.
That's all I can think of for now!
