I think I am going to stick to Polynesian. I did read reviews and looked at pictures of the Beach Club and it looks wonderful so I try to stay there on my next visit.
However, I thought long and hard about what we wanted to do/see on this trip and it came down to logistics. Since we planned to skip HS this time, BC's proximity to this park is useless. Plus if we decide to grab the 2 day park tickets instead of the 3 day, I think Epcot is the next park to get bumped off the list. I think I want to keep MK because for me there is nothing like walking down main street early in the morning and seeing that Castle in the middle of the park. It's just so magical, it sets the tone for the rest of the trip. If my kids and husband vote to keep Epcot, I will do that but if not it's on the chopping block. I know we all want to go to AK to see the new Avatar Land.
I also don't want to pass up my breakfast at Kona Cafe and dinner at Ohana'. We love those restaurants and have great memories there as a family. I also want to bring the kids to eat at California Grill. They love sushi and the views of MK from the restaurant are amazing!
So with that, Poly is just the logical choice.
Thanks everyone for helping me decide. It was a tough choice!