I have to say I really liked the Parrot Cay Menu the best. We sailed in February right after the new menus had come out. For a year all I had been hearing was how much people didn't like the Parrot Cay menu (old one), so I was pleasantly surprised to find that was my favorite!
The only downside was that was our first night, and I loved it so much I kept waiting for another night to be as good or better than that!!!