Please help with Italian night

[Jakesmom1]

I love Tutto Italia as does my DH and DS, but was thinking maybe we should try either Mama Melrose or Tonys.

Can anyone give me thier honest reviews on all?

Im really thinking we should try different restaurants this trip, but dont want to wind up dissapointed.

Thanks in advance.

 

[tortoni]

We've tried them all and I think Tutto has the best Italian. Mama Melrose would probably be my second choice--nice atmosphere.

 

[Tam1067]

We like Mama Melrose and have had dinner there twice. We're planning on lunch there in August.

Tony's was mediocre when we had dinner there way back in 2003. We haven't returned because there are so many more interesting places at WDW.

We haven't tried Tutto yet, but it's on my list for when I call for my ADRs on Mother's Day, so we'll see!

 

[webray]

Tutto is very good, so Mama's and Tony's will be a disappointment to you.

Why not try IL Mulino over at the Swan. (no dining plan or discounts, but well worth it)

 

[forgop]

I just had Tutto Italia's for lunch yesterday and found the entrees to be pretty bad. Calamari and tiramasu was good, but I could have had better italian food eating it out of a can.

 

[snowdrift7]

We've eaten at all three during the past 5 days - Tutto Italia is hands-down the best! We had a late lunch Friday and were too stuffed to eat dinner until close to 10 !! I love the atmosphere, service but I love the food most. While I was disappointed that they discontinued the sacchetti, the gnocchi and tiramisu were delicioso. We had lunch the day before at Mama Melrose - and we really like Mama's - and it didn't disappoint. But it trails Tutto Italia by quite a bit. Wanting to eat in MK we finally tried Tony's - big mistake! It was the worst food we've ever had in Disney. I tried 3 different entrees and none was edible - IMO. However, the service was very good.