Please help us decide? Porfq or pop? :)

[dmbcanada]

These we our two final picks for our Winter 12' vacation, and we ended up choosing POFQ because it was smaller and less walking since we have a young one with us. We have had family members stay at POP and they loved it, it just comes down to what suits your needs. I think POP might be suited to those on a tighter budget and who want to be Disney 24/7. POFQ just seems like it is going to be quieter and will give the adults a break from the Disney surroundings for a few hours.

 

[Daisy-J&D]

POP is small for 3 adults (including your brother because 17 is close enough!). We stayed once as a couple with my MIL and I will never stay there with more than 2 adults again... ever!
You're only going to get about 35 sq Ft. more going to POFQ but you will have QUEEN BEDS. Sharing a double bed is really uncomfortable IMO. Also the pop refurb beds are really hard. DP had a really hard time sleeping on them this past trip.