Hey Gina, We leave tomorrow for the 11/9 Western, and honestly we have still not made up our minds as to which to go to. I have read countless posts on this and other Cozumel only websites and opinions vary greatly. Each has their own web site. We may end up doing a bit of each, starting at Mr Sancho's and walking up the beach to Playa del Sol. PDS has a cover charge that varies with the services you want. IE beach access only, Beach and Drinks, Beach and food and drinks.
So, if you can wait until a few weeks til I have a chance to post a trip report, you can have one more opinion to help make your decision.
Bob