I'm concerned with the tiers as well and have a lot of questions. With
Genie+ we were able to ride ALL the headliners the park offered in a day. This does not seem like a possibility now (without waiting in the standard line). Genie+ was a cost, but a worthy one (for us). Every ride that offered LL, we used it. We got, what we felt, a GREAT value. We used the system the way it was intended to be used and paid for it. We paid to not have to wait in lines.
I know personally we go during a slower time (August), but that combined with Genie+ essentially had us walking on many rides, or never more than a ten minute wait.
1. Do we know yet what exactly the tiers are and what rides are included in them? (I'm not seeing a lot of the character meets on the lists floating around - Grotto Ariel, Princess Fairytale Hall, etc.).
2. Booking one tier 1 and two, tier 2's in advance feels pointless. For what rides I'm thinking the tier 2's are, well, those rides ALWAYS were readily available day of and 95% of them for a time with an immediate scan in or within 15 minutes. Booking these so far in advance serves no purpose.
Now, tell me I can book TWO "tier 1's" in advance, and then the third pre-book a tier 2, fine. I can see myself then scanning into the first booking early on in the day, stacking the 2 others for later, and using one throughout the day and/or letting 2 hours pass to book a new one while I met some characters or ate at a nice restaurant and stacked for later. Then we're talking!
Actually, I felt with Genie+, with the 2 hour rule, it actually had us spending more to eat at a nicer restaurant. We got to either meet characters, take a bit longer of a break. It was a very relaxing day, and even though we were spending more on food, it was so pleasant and we didn't mind. Now we will be more inclined to eat quickly so we can scan in and book the next ride.
Also, to call Thunder Mountain, Space Mountain, etc, a tier 1?? By later on in the day, after that morning rush, at least when we go in August, the times always evened out. By later on they'd be consistently readily available to hop on within 15 minutes or so. I feel like tiering them will create a different experience, and with people booking SO far out instead of day of, a lot of mixed availability come day of. Real time will turn into a confusing mess. There's also the risk of an attraction selling out FAR in advance (one that likely may not have under Genie+) because of all the pre-booking. People will then change their minds on things FAR more day (understandably, since it was booked not in real time), so if I want to hope something becomes available I need to be glued to my phone, and then also possibly change one of my reservations to grab what may randomly become available. How does that solve anything? We were tied to our phones FAR less on Genie+ then we ever were with FP+. This seems opposite.
3. I'm reading you pre-book "3" (again, kind of silly as the other 2 options were not hard to get).
So you scan into your first, then you can book another one? Does that mean the 2 hour rule is gone for sure? That was crucial to stacking.
Will they let you use one, book one continually? Or will they make you wait to use up the other 2 before you can book a 5th and 6th?
I'm confused about the rules for this.