How many people in your party? We've done both the Pirates & Pals and a private fireworks cruise. Since there were 9 of us, the private one was actually the less expensive option and it was nice to just be our own group. It's been a few years, but the cost was around $300-$350 for a boat that held 10 and less for the type that held 8. We had the music, packaged snacks and drinks all on our own boat. Both experiences were a great way to end our trips. Enjoy!