Johnny Depp is perhaps one of the most gifted actors of our time.
I can echo the knee-jerk reaction... Since he did Cry Baby he's been a heart-throb..... but he also did:
Edward Scissor-Hands (Brilliant you all know what he did)
Dead Man (Severely brilliant and dark, playing a dying man in the old west)
Fear And Loathing in Los Vegas (hilarious and brilliant playing gonzo journalist Hunter S. Thompson)
Benny and Joon (playing a handicapped romantic)
Ed Wood (as the b movie directing phenom)
Donnie Brasco (as a hard nosed under cover agent working with the mob, alongside Al Pacino)
The Ninth Gate (as a obsessed researcher seeking hell's gate)
Sleepy Hollow (as the fearful man unravelling the headless horseman mystery)
Blow (as a cocaine kingpin)
From Hell (as the drug-addicted Scotland Yard detective tracking down Jack the Ripper).
Though he is eye candy for the ladies, I think we can all agree that he is a superbely talented actor who has a long list of exceptional roles under his belt. I, for one, think Johnny Depp will add layers and depth to any pirate role he recieves, this will be a very good movie, IMHO.