We got free tickets and went a few weeks ago. I haven't been to any of the other dinner shows (so I can't compare) b/c I am allergic to horses.
The show was pretty good. There was lots of audience participation. The food was edible and there was lots of beer, wine and pop.
There is also a pre-show. There is a appetizer buffet with salad, various pasta, chips & salsa, crudites, etc. There are several bars where you can purchase alcohol. There is a pirate museum, gift shop and a tarot card reader ($10 for adults and $5 for children under 12).
DD has been to Medieval Times in Myrlte Beach. She liked that show MUCH better.