I can't answer your question about what night your pirate night falls on. You may want to check with
DCL. Palo brunch is no longer a buffet, but a set menu that is brought to your table. I really enjoy brunch. I am not a big buffet person-I found all the food and all the choices overwhelming. There is plenty to eat at Palo brunch, I would be surprised if you left hungry. A quick google search and you should be able to find the menus and how everything is currently offered. We order different things per person and that way we can all try a bite or two of the offerings. Palo dinner- also pretty wonderful Quiet, really good service. Perfect adult night out if you have children traveling with you. You can choose for a prix fixe menu and add on a wine paring or a la carte. Once again, a quick internet search and you can view the menus. Which do I prefer? I like them both- for different reasons. I like the dinner as it is a quiet meal with personal attention. I find the food there to be quite good and I can order off the a la carte menu as to just what I want/and how many courses. A nice break from main dinning. The brunch is just a lovely way to spend a sea day, eat a lot (lol) and still enjoy the main dinning room rotation in the evening. Sometimes I will do both or just either or. Depends on my itiernary, excursions etc. I try not to book Palo the first night, as I wish to meet my serving team that I will have in the main dinningrooms and establish my relationship with them. Or the last night, as I usually like to say good-bye to them. Hope this is helpfu. Enjoy your cruise!