Pin Trading

fey_spirit

DIS Veteran
Joined
Sep 19, 2006
Messages
1,602
I have been looking at some of the cheaper places to get offical pins, and they are still a little too rich for my blood. You see, I don't want to trade for fame, wealth or glory - just for fun... well, fun and a great way to meet people and strike up conversations in line.

That said I know there are those cheaper "pro" pins out there and I was wondering if CMs would be willing to trade with an adult (sans any children at all) adult. It might be a great way to seed my collection so I can engage in this for a budget that meets my goal of "for fun and nothing else".
 
I heartily encourage you to go ahead and and get better pins. The thing to remember is that when you trade with CMs, you aren't just trading with the CM, you are trading with other guests by proxy. Lots of us trade just for fun, and it has nothing to do with money... but seeing a lot of chintzy cheaper pins placed on lanyard (such as Propins and Sedesma pins) takes a lot of the fun out of it. Not just for other guests, but for a lot of the CMs who participate in trading (and they definitely aren't in it for the money).

To keep pin trading a fun hobby that is a great tradition at WDW, it's best, and very much in the spirit of Disney, for us all to do what we can to keep it fun for everyone! So I encourage you to buy some decent official pins. You should be able to get a lot in the $2-$3 per pin range. I guarentee it will make for a far more rewarding experience for you and for everyone participating in Official Pin Trading at WDW! :wizard:
 
FigNewton,

I would love to go with the really good pins - and I guess that I probably should...
except I can't afford it. 30 bucks for ten pins plus shipping and handeling is just a little too rich for my blood. Esp when I'm not even sure if ten pins is enough to even really get started playining the trading game.

On the other hand you make a good point - and maybe I should just accept that I don't have the money to play and watch from the bench due to lack of funds...
 
In the overall scope of things, is $30 really that much in comparison to the total cost of a Disney vacation? Especially when the pin trading will be an on-going thing, not just a one-shot deal like a meal or something.
 

First it wouldn't be 30 dollars - it would be more like 45 - 50 once you added shipping and handeling, probably a little more then that once you add a lanyard. And the over all cost of the trip is kind of the problem.

I budgeted only so much for this trip (Which required a huge sacrafice from both the spouse and I in the order of limiting our entertainment budget to reading books for free at the local bookstore for six months). So we manage to put aside just barely the money we had budgeted - then wow we get the promise of maybe 5 or 6 hundred more from my Pel grant.

So what's the problem with spending that? All of a sudden my mom wants me to start paying a hundered dollars every other week for groceries instead of 80, and oh yeah can I pay so she doesn't lose her nurse's liscense? And oh yeah, the step monster is going to clean the rugs - and it's my job to pay for renting the machine and buying the supplies. Oh and wait! The insurance - she wants us to help her finish paying the house insurance!

Now - to be specific, yes I live with my mom (It started out as us needing a place to stay when we first moved back to Ky, then it turned into her not having a job and needing us to support her, then she had the heart attack and the boyfriend moved in so it became a matter of staying here to protect her from his abusive self on top of the financial issues.) who is functionally unemployed. (She works at Neilson, I doubt anyone is familar with that that means so let me be specific. That means she's really lucky to make minimum wage - and get twelve hours a week. Yeah - tons of help that is. Then the there's the other housemates, her 48 year old boyfriend who only works the summer season - and even then whines and screams and jumps up and down in a remarkable display that is a cross between the Incredible Hulk and Rumplestilskin. (Imagine the Hulk if he really had an anger problem). He brings with him his son, and his son's best friends - neither of whom pay a penny to stay here. Finally we have me and D.

Needless to say, while Scotty and his two boys live here for maybe 3 hundred a month (Which according to the math I do - justice would demand more like 1,000, I'll explain in a second), D and I pay out more like 440 on top of everything else she now wants me to pay for. Now, as to my math from before? Me and D - 300 (Which before he moved in and started keeping a radio and light on for his chickens 24/7, and started watering his small farm of animals (like 78 dogs) and driving the water bill up, were well under 300 dollars) on utilities and 140 on food (Now being moved to more like 200 on food a month). I Get the 1,000 figure from them accordingly. If they were to match the 300 D and I put in in a fair way, then it would be 300 between Scotty and Mom, and another 300 between the two boys (Who are fully grown, and well over 18) plus two hundered for food from each set - that's 1,000 dollars - we could all afford to live not hand to mouth and it wouldn't feel like it was all on our heads.

Now, on top of all that drama - Scotty is extremly verbally abusive to not only my mother (or not even mostly my mother) but to D and I as well. There are lots of unfair orders being bandied about (We ignore him, but that only makes him angrier), he calls us such wonderful gems as fat lazy, b&t**s several times daily, and makes tons of wonderful homophobic commentary about our relationship - including the ever popular threats of hellfire and damendation (because he's a Christan don't ya know). SO, now D - quite understandably - wants to move out in January. Our trip is in December.

She didn't tell me she wanted to move out (remember I'm still hanging in trying to protect the mother that refuses to protect me from her boyfreind... and probably a little because I don't like the idea of being forced out of my mother's home by that man, so this comes as quite a shock to me.) in January until after we had started paying on a 3,000 plus package. She didn't tell me she wanted to move out until the budget was set in stone... So now I have to find the money to do that.

Now to top all of this off, I receive and SSI check as my sole source of income, I have a disability which prevents me from being able to function in the kind of work I can get without a degree. (Before anyone bandies around that awful word "freeloader" please understand that I am working with the state to attend university so that I can get a degree that will allow me to work despite my disability). And D is making around 12 dollars an hour, working full time at Cardnial health. I tell you this so you will understand our financial circumstances and exactly what our resources are.

So, now I'm sure you're asking the same question I've asked myself a hundred times. "Why are you even going to WDW under these circumstances? Why not just cancel the trip and move into a safer enviorment?"

Well, see it's bad enough that Scotty is going to drive me out of my own mother's house just when she and I are really starting to get along for the very first time in my life... but he can't have my dream too. WDW is my dream, it has been since I was a very little girl. The whole trip got decided on after I made a list of the things that I would mourn on my deathbed if I never did - and WDW was at the top of my list. I think it's something about giving something to the wounded, and abused child inside of me (I grew up in an enviorment that was highly abusive on all levels verbal, sexual, emotional, psychological, and physical.) the chance to find the magic that every child deserves. So he may force me out of my own home - but he will not force me out of my dream. And now? They tell me I might have cancer (nothing definitive yet - but there is still that chance, and that my time might be running out. So now he's really not cheating me out of my dream.

So you take all of those factors, and the nightmares I'm already having about not being able to make it... and that I never thought I would get into the whole Pin Trading thing until I held one in my hands that came from a wonderful Fairygodmailer unexpectedly... and yeah... 45 - 60 dollars seems like it might be just a little too much.

Sorry, guess I needed to get all of that off my chest.






EpcotMatt said:
In the overall scope of things, is $30 really that much in comparison to the total cost of a Disney vacation? Especially when the pin trading will be an on-going thing, not just a one-shot deal like a meal or something.
 
I just bought 12 cast lanyard pins for $35 including shipping---that's just barely $3.00 a pin. They are really nice...some I intend to keep and most I will be happy to trade. Have never traded before so I hope I don't get any of the "cheapo" ones in trade. (Are they that noticeably different?)
 
That 2.50 to 3 per pin estimate was a actualy breakdown *after* shipping. And you really don't have to have a lanyard. It's a convenience, and fun for some, but you'd be surprised by the number of people who don't like wearing them. Some put pins on their bags, on a hat, on a jacket... it's all good!

For instance, check out auctions from pincastle on eBay. They have a bunch of 10 pin lots up, and they usually end in the $20-$30 range, and their shipping is free. And that's just the tip of the iceberg as far as what's out there. If you were to end up buying Propins, for example, you'd probably be paying close to $2 per pin anyway. The price differential isn't really that much! :thumbsup2

I understand that costs can be difficult to deal with. We all have to make those decisions of what we can and cannot afford, and they can be difficult ones to make. I'd sure like to be getting a PS3 in November but that's gonna have to wait a while. ;)
 
pbnjrockette said:
I just bought 12 cast lanyard pins for $35 including shipping---that's just barely $3.00 a pin. They are really nice...some I intend to keep and most I will be happy to trade. Have never traded before so I hope I don't get any of the "cheapo" ones in trade. (Are they that noticeably different?)

Most of the time, they are very noticeably different.
 
Could you tell me how to find these Pincastle people (or person) on E Bay?


FigNewton said:
For instance, check out auctions from pincastle on eBay. They have a bunch of 10 pin lots up, and they usually end in the $20-$30 range, and their shipping is free. And that's just the tip of the iceberg as far as what's out there. If you were to end up buying Propins, for example, you'd probably be paying close to $2 per pin anyway. The price differential isn't really that much! :thumbsup2
 
I was only using the $30 figure because that's the figure you originally listed.
 
I think pincastle may be going out of business. I just got (my first ever e-bay purchase) a lot of 20 pins (all official traders-pictured in the auction) fro $52 with shipping thats like 2.60 a pin- in the parks they're 8.50 and up.

I understand more than anyone trying to get a deal- I am the queen of it. My husband and I live beyon our means most of the time- because, well, I'm a snob and I'm Po' . However, I do agree that there is a moral dilema involved here. Putting out lesser quality pins for ppl who may not know better is unfair. You know about propins but other guests may not. And most likely they've paid $8 for the pins they are trading w/ the cm's. What happens to that 5 or 10 yo when they try to trade that pro pin and someone says" hey that's a crappy pin you can't trade that!" You, inadverantly and indirectly will have caused this kid sadness- Disney is not about that- it should be magical for EVERYONE. You can have as much fun w/ 3 trading pins as 10. I know b/c as I've posted here more than once my DS and DH always trade all of my pins. I have been looking for the same set of pins the last 3 trips(I want all of the parking lot signs)- and so I always have pins to trade cause if I don't find what I'm looking for then I don't trade- unless a child asks to trade with me- then of course I get the parents permission and anything on my lanyard is game. I don't put pins I wont trade on my lanyard, except 1 special pin at the bottom- to hold it together.
I look at it like a game. I figure out what I want to find then look at EVERY lanyard possible to find it. the fun- for me- is in the hunt.

I have been trading for 3 years now and out of the 3 of us we only have about 30 pins(not counting the newly won lot) I am about to do my first official big girl trade w/ pin girl- who's gonna be at WDW next weekend too. I'm looking forward to meeting her and aquiring a new special pin- but I've had just as much fun trading leisurely w/ cast members and that will probably be the way I continue to do most of my trading
Good luck and have fun on your trip! Like I always say- "It's only magical if you let it be!"
...t.
 
fey_spirit said:
Could you tell me how to find these Pincastle people (or person) on E Bay?

Certainly! You can search for particular dealers on eBay by going to the advanced search screen. The fourth section down in the Advanced search is "From Sellers". Choose the option for "from specific sellers" and 'include' from the drop down menu (should be the default), and put the name of the seller you are searching for in the field next to it. Hit enter, and voila!
 












Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE













DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top