amy4bruce said:
DD6

handles the pin trading in my family. This year, we've bought 17 pins from Ebay dealers, and she'll take every opportunity to trade them, until she is satisfied with what she has. Last year, she stopped on the fifth day, saying that she didn't want to trade the pins she wound up with.
If the CM has a green lanyard, they will only trade with children, which gives DD6 an advantage there.
It doesn't excite me, but the look on DD6's face when she makes a trade certainly does.
I didn't know that about the green lanyard, we will definitely keep that in mind! My DS6 and DS8 love pin trading. We don't trade with other visitors, just CM's. We started about 3 years ago, and they have about 30 pins each..(the lanyards are so full, that we just pick out the ones we want to get rid of for the day and put them into a plastic baggie. Then we don't have to carry the heavy lanyard around, or, as it happened one trip, almost lose it by leaving it laying in the boneyard at animal Kingdom--DH...

OR worry about the pins falling off the lanyard..) I have only bought one keeper for each, they really wanted them, so Santa brought them at Christmas. Whenever there is a promotion for trading pins ( I have gotten them for next to nothing through a cereal promo, and Smuckers had one not too long ago...I got 9 of the same pin..) I get as many cheap ones that I can..then we can trade some and keep one. I bought a bunch from an online store-they came out to be about $2.30 each including s/h...Most are German..or whatever language is on the card..LOL, some are cute, ALL are official, and so we just trade the ugly ones. The Disny online store had Incredibles pins for 2 or 3 dollars, I bought a bunch to trade. I buy the ugly ones so it doens't bother us to get rid of them..
I have seen the folks at the trading pin store with their "suitcases" of pins...this seems to be a little extreme to me, but I guess it is a way of meeting people, and enjoying Disney. I don't think this is a way to make money as some people might think...
my boys also LOVE the penny press machines. Before we go out into the park, I am at the cash register at the resort, making change, gathering quarters, and asking the poor CM to give me all the shiny pennies! This year I have been collecting all the shiny pennies at home, so we are ready. After the $6 for the little collecting book, it is the cheapest souvenir at WDW-51 cents, no tax!! They are constantly taking their books out while walking around to inspect their pennies...Since we don't collect autographs, (they don't like to get near the characters) this is fun for them...
To the OP, there actually ARE a set of rules for pin trading. You should get a little brochure about it when you check in..One good one is that you do not touch the CM or their lanyard. You ask about the pins, and they will hold it out for you to see. Can't remember the other rules, they are mostly common sense...
( I just noticed your name, amy4bruce. I have (had, she passed away last year) a dear friend whose daughter Amy married Bruce about 10 years ago...I think she has two boys, though...maybe I am wrong..could it be you?)