Sarah, I looked at pinpics, and if the numbers of their members trading that pin vs. those wanting that pin are accurate, the WV pin is in EXTREMELY HIGH demand. 117 people want the pin and 0 (that's zero, none, no one) is offering it for trade.
I'm not sure what might be an equitable trade for the WV pin. Probably a low LE pin, but maybe not the level of a Wet Paint or Mickey for President. Anyone else have any insight? What have other people traded the WV pin for, or traded to get the WV pin?