Thursday, October 22nd - You Can't Make All of the People Happy All of the Time...
To be totally honest, Jay and I had no real interest in returning to CA Grill on this trip; our previous dinner had been medicore at best and we really felt like it was time to give the place a rest. BUT ... we wanted to take X&Y someplace nice for their final vacation meal and they can be rather picky at times and one of them doesn't (or didn't at the time) eat fish, so our options were rather limited. CA Grill seemed like a safe and easy choice as long as the food wasn't sucky like the last time. I even timed the reservation so that we could watch the damn fireworks from the restaurant, something that Jay and I typically never do.
We checked in downstairs and I made the request for a window table, saying that we would wait if necessary because we were celebrating someone's first wedding anniversary. I'd hoped that would garner a little extra attention for X&Y, but it didn't; we didn't even score any Mickey confetti but we did get a great table so I won't complain!
First things first ... we needed some drinks! I tried a French martini here a few years ago and it's remained one of my favorites ever since - it's kind of like a Cosmo with champagne. The nephew wanted to try something but wasn't sure what, so we suggested a Lemon Drop ... a nice blend of sweet and tart, and most people seem to like it. Jay ordered a vodka martini with extra fat olives!
French Martini
Dylan & the Lemondrop
Jay and the James Bond Special
Obligatory Sunset pic...
And then it was time for the feasting to begin!! Since the nephew has been stretching his wings in regard to sushi, we decided to order Yoshie's Deluxe Sushi Platter so that there would be good variety for him (and us) to munch on. Because his wifey doesn't ...
er, didn't at the time that I made the reservation... like fish, we also ordered a flatbread to share. In this case we selected the Triple Cheese flatbread, which seemed like a tasty and safe choice.
Yoshi's platter of fishie joy!
Triple Cheese Flatbread
The sushi was wonderful - fresh and sweet and oh-so-delectable! The flatbread was also quite good; it was made with Pecorino, Asiago, and Provolone cheeses with sun-dried tomatoes and Arugula Pesto. We requested the Pesto on the side, just to err on the side of intestinal caution.
Sushi sampler
flatbread
Ain't they cute?
Are we too old to be cute now?
After sharing some appetizers it was time to order more ... as in individual appetizers .. oink oink!
Jay went with more sushi; this time the Spicy Kazan Roll, which was crab, shrimp, bay scallops, tuna, and fireball sauce.
Elia Kazan Roll???
I ordered the Florida Beefsteak Tomato Soup with Herbed Mascarpone and Pumpernickel Croutons. Mmmmmm, this was wonderful - rich and thick and creamy - could have only been better with a toasted cheese sandwedge!
Tomato soup
Dylan ordered the other item that I seriously considered: Maine Lobster Risotto with Midnight Moon Goat Cheese, Lobster Oil, and Meyer Lemon Beurre Blanc. This was just as good as everyone around here was saying; it was almost too rich but since I didn't actually order it, who cares?
YUM!
And then it was dinner time. That's right, we ordered even more food!
Jay and Dylan both ordered the same thing: Seared Ostrich Filet with Buttery Potato Puree, Wild Mushrooms, Globe Carrots, Fig, and Honeyed Port Reduction.
Ostrich, view I
Ostrich, view II
I ordered the Day Boat Scallops with House-made Gnocchi, Sustainable Pears, Brown Butter, and Bacon Emulsion. It was tough to pass on the pork tenderloin because I love that goat cheese polenta but I was determined to try all new foods on this CA Grill visit and the scallops sounded really good.
Scallops
This was excellent ... a terrific combination of flavors that were just right - not too salty and not too sweet - and the scallops were cooked perfectly. I would order this again in a heartbeat.
And the nephew's wifey ... the guest who didn't like fish or sushi or meat ... what did she order?
She ordered sushi.

Apparently earlier in the week she tried a California Roll, thought it was good, and became addicted to them. Good for her ... honestly, I've been there ... I know what it's like. But damn I was annoyed for a moment. I spent months agonizing over just the right restaurant, trying to find a place that would offer everyone a nice variety without disregarding anyone's likes or dislikes and she ordered sushi. I swear I heard Grimace laughing somewhere in the distance.

Ah well, the important thing is that she liked it and has slowly been discovering the joy of mild fish, so hopefully she will continue to build on that and find more things that she enjoys.
California Roll
And you know we had to order dessert so that we could watch Hallowishes. I left the decision as to where to watch the fireworks to X&Y and they opted for remaining at the table. We had a wonderful viewing spot right there at the corner of the restaurant - best table in the house for watching fireworks. And how sad is it that I actually know the words to the Hallowishes chorus? Jay found it amusing but I'm pretty sure X&Y thought it was too weird for words.
Dylan selected the Bananas & Caramel: crispy baked phyllo squares layered with banana, caramel, mascarpone mousse, and caramelized bananas. I don't usually like banana desserts but this was good - the mousse was especially light and tasty.
Naners and mousse
Jason ordered the Valrhona Chocolate Cake: warm chockie cake with a molten center, house-made salted caramel ice cream, and roasted golden pineapple. One word says it all: YUM!
Sinfully good
And I had no choice but to finish off the evening with a cheese plate and a glass of Fonseca 20-year Tawny port. I loved their cheese plate that night and the port was terrific ... what a great end to the meal! From left to right in the picture below: Tete de Moine, Pont L'eveque, Fog Light, Brebicet, and Bleu des Basques Brebis.
Cheese plate!
For Grimace!
All in all we had one of the best meals of the entire trip at California Grill - it was good enough this time that we would definitley consider going back ... again ... this coming October. Jay and I were really pleased that the dinner was so good - no one wants to take someone out for a nice meal only to end up being served crap on a cracker. We got a great table with great service and great food - what more can you ask for?