Pick Any American Idol From Any Season...

[Brutie]

That you'd most like to meet, get to know better or be alone with in a dark room...


For me I'm gonna have to pick Constantine...My oh my, what that boy does to my innards...
Wonder if he likes older women who could teach him a thing or 3?

 

[Rafiki Rafiki Rafiki]

Constantine kinda freaks me out.

It's a toss up between Taylor and Chris for me.

 

[Brutie]

Taylor is lovable like a teddy bear and Chris is sexy also, but for me Constantine is the one I'd spend my time with. The sad thing is, I have no idea why he does anything for me, he just does...LOL

 

[Robinrs]

See sig....

But I also had a Stella Got her Groove Back crush on Ace!

 

[AllyandJack]

Since I'm 29, I guess Taylor, Bo, and Constantine would be my only viable options. I choose Taylor. But, the room doesn't have to be dark.....lights dimmed maybe....not that I've thought about this....

 

[lucyblondecat]

Yuk, Constatine gives me the heebie jeebies. Maybe not as much as that swarmy Corey Clark, but pretty darned close.

My faves are Taylor, just because he's so incredibly sure of himself, which makes any man sexy; and Chris, because he seems like a good family man.

 

[gypsydoodlebug]

Ace. I'm a "dirty boy" kind of girl, but this pretty fella sure was fun ta look at!

And I have to admit, Justin Guarini was cute, too. I'm one of the three people who actually saw "From Justin to Kelly..." Just don't tell anyone...

 

[CheapMom]

William Hung

he bang

 

[kcork1026]

Usually I go for the "good" boy, but I have 3 that make me melt....Constatine, Bo and of course Chris

 

[tiggger1]

Constantine is a cool kid. I did a show with him in 97? and got to hang out with him at rehearsals for about month....it wasnt a dark closet but it was a dark theater, does that count?

 

[Fantasmic303]

I suppose my response to this is assumed...

However, let me note that in any future meetings with Mr. Aiken, I promise to make a sincere effort to NOT step on him. Again.

 

[jennyl772003]

I would have to say Chris, but Taylor would be a close second.

Now Constantine...YUCK!!!! What is it with that stupid pout of his? I hope he looks back on that footage someday and sees how dumb he looked! As soon as he saw the camera on him yesterday he struck his pout pose! ACK! ACK! DOUBLE ACK!!!