Nice shots! At what point in your workflow did you use PS stats?
Thanks!
The only one of the above photos that I used Stats on was the Tomorrowland image. For that one -- in the revised image at least -- I first sorted the Base, -4, -2, +2 and +4 exposures into separate groups just for my convenience. I then used Bridge and ACR to examine the photos in each group in turn. For the underexposed images, I opened them all in Camera Raw and applied additional exposure and fill light so that I could see whether there were any people in the photos and where they were, and made a note of those exposures that featured only a few guests in different areas. For the stats trick to work, you need at least three images with no guests in a given spot in at least two of those images. Then I canceled any adjustments I made and went to Photoshop and ran the stats trick on the photos I had noted. I think I chose four shots from most of the groups, but I remember that one only needed three. I ran the trick on each group, and confirmed that it had worked as desired in each case. I did that the same way I examined the original images -- in Camera Raw, applying temporary exposure boosts to the underexposed images. I saved each guest-scrubbed resulting image as a TIFF and then turned them over to Photomatix to make an HDR, just as if I had started with RAW images.
Of course, after I completed working in Photomatix, I took the result back into ACR to apply more corrections there, and finally tweaked it further in Photoshop to create the final image.
I shot the image of the Torii Gate with the idea that I would have to use the same trick on it -- I probably shot eight to ten bracketed sets of that one over the course of almost an hour because guests kept walking through the shot, especially during the long overexposures. I expected that -- I was standing well back from the gate so I could zoom in on it (to make Spaceship Earth look as large as possible), which meant there was a large expanse through which guests could stroll, and it's a high-traffic area. That last was offset by it being after IllumiNations, but I knew it would still be a problem for my purposes.
A couple of years ago, I shot essentially the same image during the day, and
that was even harder because there were lots more guests around. I used manual Photoshop work to fix that one. I used Photomatix on several bracketed sequences and applied the same settings to each one, then combined the results in a layered Photoshop document and used layer masks -- and eventually, a little bit of cloning -- to remove the guests. That was much more difficult than using Stats.
After all that, however, I discovered that my third bracketed set of the Torii Gate -- shot about five minutes into the hour I spent there -- was completely free of guests from beginning to end. Somehow, I missed that when I was shooting it! So I didn't need to use Stats after all.
I do wish I had zoomed in just a bit more. I wanted SSE to fill the opening in the gate as much as possible. But it was dark, obviously, so it was a little difficult to see how close I had it. I think I was zoomed to about 60 mm. Still, it's acceptably large.
I may have some other images yet to process that will need it -- not sure yet.
Scott