We got off the Magic a couple days ago. We bought the photo CD after much back and forth (prior to the cruise, DH scoffed at the thought of buying it for $400), we're one cabin with 3 people. We started off with the smallest photo package, and as the cruise went on and more photos were taken, we upgraded to the largest package, and ultimately the photo CD.
We did find prints in Shutters that were not on the photo kiosk, so had to make a request on the last night of the cruise to have those added. We picked up the CD on the morning of debarkation, got to check the contents of the CD on their laptop and that's when we found some of the images were small - like as small as 300kb in size! I know those photographers were using fancy cameras capable of much larger images. In fact, on the CD, we have one image that is 4MB and one that is 1MB (processed in some way) - of the EXACT SAME SHOT. The Shutters staff claim that what is on the CD is unaltered, it is the raw jpeg that they took. But no way were they taking 1MB (or smaller) pictures! Has anyone else had this issue??
I plan to follow up on this and will post what ends up happening. I don't know yet if we'll have buyers regret on this; we printed out some 4x6s yesterday from the images and those look fine, but I don't know if the 8x10s will come out like they did on the Shutters prints. The Shutters staff said they have a "guarantee" that all the images will print out well as a 8x10 so we have to try that. I do have to say that the Shutters prints were fantastic quality ( on Kodak Royal digital paper), Costco is not as good, and I really hope that what we have printed out by a photo lab looks as good, otherwise I will not be a happy camper.